Ohio lakes · Carroll County, Tuscarawas County

Atwood Lake

Atwood Lake is a 1,540-acre reservoir the Muskingum Watershed Conservancy District finished in 1936, flooding the unplatted village of Atwood on Indian Fork.

  • Built 1936
  • 1540 acres
  • Indian Fork of Conotton Creek
  • Muskingum Watershed Conservancy District
  • Published , updated

Summer temperature by depth

Atwood Lake stratifies in summer: a warm upper layer sits on colder water below, and the two barely mix until the fall turnover.

Across 40 deep-water summer profiles measured 1976-2016, the thermocline, where the water turns sharply colder, sat about 21 ft down (half of them between 18 and 24 ft). Surface water averaged 77 °F; the deepest readings, about 30 ft down, averaged 69 °F.

Below about 16 ft the water usually held less than 2 milligrams of oxygen per litre, too little for most fish, until the lake turned over in the fall.

0 ft 10 ft 20 ft 30 ft 65°F 70°F 75°F 80°F thermocline July August
Average water temperature at each depth in July and August, across every measured profile.

Past measurements, not live readings: EPA National Lakes Assessment 2007 (hydrographic profile file nla2007_profile_20091008.csv), 1 profile 2007; Ohio Lake Management Society (Volunteer), 83 profiles 2010-2016; U.S. Army Corps of Engineers / Water Management, 6 profiles 2010; USGS Ohio Water Science Center, 2 profiles 1976. From the Water Quality Portal, the EPA National Lakes Assessment and the Army Corps' lake records.

Atwood Lake sits on the Carroll–Tuscarawas county line in east-central Ohio, a 1,540-acre reservoir on the Indian Fork of Conotton Creek built in the 1930s for the Muskingum Watershed Conservancy District (MWCD). It's one of ten MWCD lakes that hold a permanent pool, and it carries the name of a village that no longer exists, a town whose own historical marker says it was never formally platted before the dam put it under water.

At a glance

FactValue
BuiltWork began August 12, 1935; dam completed September 1936 (Corps, 1975 and 2002); contract completion extended to September 23, 1937
BuilderU.S. Army Corps of Engineers; contractor W. L. Johnson Construction Co., Hicksville, Ohio (2002 manual)
Construction cost$1,403,900 (Corps, 1975); $1,399,920 estimated across U.S., District and State Highway shares (1937)
Dam typeRolled earth fill with impervious core (1975)
Dam height65 feet structural (1975); 55 feet hydraulic (National Inventory of Dams)
Dam length3,700 feet, 30 feet wide at top, 360 feet at base (1975)
Normal pool1,540 acres at 928 feet (1975); 1,562 acres on the state fishing map (2010)
Maximum flood pool2,460 acres at 941 feet (1975)
Storage (normal / max flood)23,600 / 49,700 acre-feet (1975)
Maximum depth41 feet (MWCD fact card, 1986)
Drainage area70 square miles (1975)
Land taken108.92 acres in fee at the damsite, 5,148.15 acres of easement in the reservoir (1975)
MWCD park land3,080 acres (MWCD, 2026)
OperatorCorps of Engineers owns and operates the dam; MWCD owns and runs the lands and waters (MWCD, 1986)
StreamIndian Fork of Conotton Creek, a tributary of the Tuscarawas River
CountiesCarroll, Tuscarawas
Shoreline28 miles (MWCD, 1986); 28.4 miles (state fishing map, 2010)
Motor limit25 horsepower (MWCD)
Visitors1,231,200 (Corps estimate, 1974); 1,011,927 (MWCD estimate, 2022)
Park revenue$3,170,026 (Atwood Lake Park, 2022)
Cottage sites365 (MWCD, 2022)
Oil and gas wells on MWCD land42 (MWCD, 2014)
Record high pool (gauge record since 2015)934.66 feet, April 6, 2026
Record low pool (gauge record since 2015)915.05 feet, November 28, 2016
Hazard classificationHigh (National Inventory of Dams)

Before the lake

The valley the dam now floods was farmed and settled well before Ohio thought about damming it. An 1875 county atlas of Tuscarawas County's Warren Township, read directly off the original plat page, shows Indian Fork running south out of New Cumberland through a string of named farms: Edward Richardson, William Strawn, Wilson and McGregor, Wm. Leggett, Jacob Vail, the Lappin family, Daniel Smith, Jno. Taggart, and the J. Sutet estate, ranging from under 50 acres to William Strawn's 747-acre tract, all directly astride the stream corridor the reservoir's east arm now covers.

The village the lake is named for, Atwood, started out in the 1820s as a settlement called Oak Dale and was, unusually for a place that lasted over a century, never formally recorded on a plat map. By 1834, baptismal records of the local United Presbyterian Church already describe it as "a thriving village." At its peak it held a post office, two general stores, a cooperage, an undertaker, a creamery, two churches, a blacksmith shop, a school and a town hall. Its fortunes had already turned before MWCD ever showed up, though: the railroad built in 1878 pulled village business away to its own site, and the post office at Atwood was discontinued in 1915, two decades before the dam. The line that served the valley in the dam era was the Carrollton branch of the Wheeling & Lake Erie, which by 1934 carried no passengers and ran one turn-around freight train three days a week between Atwood and Dell Roy; one photo caption instead names the Cleveland, Canton and Southern for the original depot.

Dellroy, at the lake's east end, predates the reservoir by nearly a century: founded in 1849 as Cannonsburg and renamed around 1878, it's an incorporated village today and was never flooded. New Cumberland lies near the dam's west end; the 1934 plan placed the damsite four miles southeast of it, and a USGS gauge on Indian Fork below the dam carries its name. Both survive on the lake's perimeter; only Atwood itself was taken.

Building the dam

The catalyst for the entire Muskingum system was the Great Flood of March 1913, which MWCD itself still calls one of the worst floods on record in the watershed. A 1950s magazine feature preserved in the Tuscarawas County library's files adds that Ohio's great drought of 1930 "emphasized anew the need for the Muskingum program", and that the people of Zanesville raised money for the first flood-control survey some fifteen years after 1913, headed by engineer Dr. Arthur Morgan. Morgan went on to serve as President Roosevelt's first chairman of the Tennessee Valley Authority, 1933 to 1938.

MWCD was organized as a political subdivision of Ohio on June 3, 1933, and on March 29, 1934, a contract between the United States and MWCD authorized the Army Corps of Engineers to build the district's 14 dams and reservoirs, backed by a $22,090,000 federal appropriation. Atwood sits in the Tuscarawas system alongside Dover, Bolivar, Leesville, Beach City, Tappan, Clendening and Piedmont.

In September 1934 the district's plan described the Atwood dam as an earth embankment 3,700 feet long and 69 feet high that would form a lake of 1,775 acres, most of it in Carroll County, at an estimated cost of $1,044,100. State Route 39 and about 12 miles of county, township and lesser roads lay in the reservoir site. In June 1935 the Atwood bids were among the last three in the system still to be opened, and the Carrollton paper noted that while the dam itself would stand outside the county, about seven-eighths of the land under the lake would be in Carroll County. The contract went to the W. L. Johnson Construction Company of Hicksville, Ohio, with notice to proceed on August 1, 1935; work began August 12, 1935, and change orders stretched the final completion date from January 8 to September 23, 1937. That August, a new railway siding was laid for the Atwood dam at the old Standard Sand & Machine Co. site.

When Atwood went up has been muddled for decades, and the Corps' own record settles most of it. The 1975 condition sheet in the 1977 federal environmental impact statement says flatly that "the dam was completed in September 1936," at a construction cost of $1,403,900. A 1937 Corps history breaks the estimated cost down as $798,978 from the United States, $296,050 from the Conservancy District and $304,892 from the State Highway Department, totaling $1,399,920. An MWCD pamphlet from the mid-1960s gives the district-wide construction start as February 1935 and a dedication in July 1938, and a district timeline panel names Tappan Dam as the system's first project. A separate MWCD fact card, library-stamped 1986, states that "Atwood Reservoir was constructed in 1937", which matches the contract's extended 1937 completion date rather than the dam itself.

The dam, per the 1937 Corps history, sits "on Indian Fork Creek, 3 miles northwest of Sherrodsville and 9 miles north of New Philadelphia," built of "rolled earth, gravel and rock fill," roughly 65 feet high and 3,700 feet long, with an embankment containing about 302,000 cubic yards of fill. An uncontrolled chute spillway near the left (south) abutment has a crest at elevation 941 feet, 95 feet long, rated for 12,800 cubic feet per second; once the pool reaches that height, water spills with no further control from the Corps. The spillway was first planned through the north abutment and moved to the south side to avoid a curved channel, which explains why the 1937 history still places it on the north. Excavation for the outlet's service bridge found coal at the planned foundation level, so the center pier was set 3 feet lower. The outlet is an intake with three 3½-by-7-foot gated conduits through the south abutment, with a siphon in each outer conduit to hold the minimum pool.

Building it meant clearing infrastructure out of the Indian Fork valley. The 1937 Corps history lists 16.5 miles of telegraph and telephone line, half a mile of electric line, 6 miles of gas line with two valve stations, and 8.8 miles of secondary road to be relocated, and its relocations table carries $103,500 for the Wheeling & Lake Erie Railway at Atwood. The railroad was not moved, though. On June 19, 1936, the Wheeling & Lake Erie applied to the Interstate Commerce Commission to abandon about 11.87 miles of its Carrollton branch, from 2.8 miles west of Carrollton to 0.7 mile north of Sherrodsville, telling the commission it would receive $100,000 from the federal government and $30,000 from the district for damages and right of way. The county expected to lose about $5,110 a year in railroad taxes, most of it from the Monroe Township duplicate. By November 1936 the track had been taken up and the 65 men who did the work transferred to Cleveland, and in January 1937 the railroad deeded right-of-way back to farmers along the line, among them Elroy C. Herron, Edwin E. and Perry J. Ferrall, Laura Gotschall, Andy Kovach, Guy Beamer and the Monroe Township trustees.

The land and the court cases

The land came from farm families, some by sale and some through the courts. By June 1935 the district had bought 373.2 acres in the Atwood dam area, part of 5,197.89 acres purchased across 13 dam areas. By July 1936 it had purchased 880 acres there and held options on 1,236 more. The finished project took 108.92 acres in fee at the damsite and easements on 5,148.15 acres in the reservoir.

Owners who would not accept the district's appraisal got a jury. In April 1938 the case of the district against Charles Creamer of Monroe Township was tried before Carroll County Common Pleas Judge Frank F. Cope; the jury, after visiting the farm and hearing six witnesses for each side, allowed $3,530 on land in the Atwood dam district that the district had appraised at $1,967. The award broke down as $1,760 for 32 acres of bottom land appraised at $1,210, $1,740 for damage to the remaining 66 acres the district had put at $756, and $30 for an easement appraised at $1. The Free Press-Standard described the appropriation as a 99-acre tract.

The Carroll Journal called the next case on the docket a similar one. In May 1938 John Day of Monroe Township won an agreed verdict of $3,875: $2,845 for 39 acres taken, against the district's appraisal of $1,154, $1,000 for damage to his remaining 81 acres, and $30 for a flood easement. Cases against F. B. Stoody and Ethel Elliott of Monroe Township were also on the list, and Stoody settled that month for an agreed $3,000.

The district also raised money by assessing property owners for the flood-control benefits they received. In March 1938 the Conservancy Court approved a 50 percent flood-benefit assessment of $849,993, bringing approved assessments to $4,652,528, half of the $9,305,057 in appraised benefits. A later land dispute came decades on: in 1963 an MWCD official said an 80-acre tract needed for the Atwood Lake recreational project had been priced at $90,000 to $120,000, beyond the district's reach.

Both of the village's cemeteries, Big Spring (also called Deep Springs) on the north side of State Route 542 and Zion on Falls Road, still sit on dry land at the lake's edge, and unlike some MWCD reservoirs no grave relocation is documented here. One of the village's two churches was lost under the lake; the other, Zion Church, had already burned in a 1930 grass fire, years before the dam was finished.

Stories

A town that never had a plat map

Atwood's own 1986 historical marker states plainly that no plat was ever formally recorded for the village, an odd distinction for a place that had a post office, two general stores, two churches and a school. A dedication plaque at the corner of State Route 542 (Lodge Road) and Fargo Road now marks where the village stood, and one photo caption says the original schoolhouse still stands nearby as a private home.

A lake that waited to fill

The dam was done in 1936, but the lake behind it came later. A 1945 state conservation report noted that "Atwood Reservoir did not have any impounded water on April 1, 1940," and was opened to public fishing on October 6, 1940. That fall the state lifted its duck-hunting ban on the 14 new Muskingum reservoirs, opening an Atwood dam area of 3,463 acres.

The judge who brought sailing to the new lake

Judge Frank F. Cope, a sitting Carroll County Common Pleas judge, launched a 21-foot cat-rigged sailboat onto the new lake in 1939, the same judge who had heard the Atwood land cases. In May 1948 Cope was named commodore of Atwood Yacht Club, Inc., at a meeting of its stockholders, and that fall the club marked its formal opening with a weekend of entertainment. In 1950 it ran its first Harvest Moon Regatta, and its 2025 running was celebrated as the 75th annual. The club today races Thistle, Highlander, MC Scow and Cruising JAM fleets, runs over 100 private member docks and a junior sailing program, and for its 75th anniversary earned Clean Regatta certification while reissuing a commemorative "Main Sail Ale" from its own microbrewery.

A resort that closed twice and became a treatment center

The Atwood Lake Resort and Conference Center opened in the 1960s, with a main hotel, two golf courses, 17 vacation cabins and indoor and outdoor pools, and local officials put its economic impact on Carroll County at about $7 million a year. Then it closed twice in six years. Losses topping $1 million in each of 2009 and 2010 led MWCD to close the complex effective October 4, 2010, and the property was approved for donation to the Carroll County commissioners in 2012. It reopened under new management, then closed again in March 2016. What followed was a summer 2016 auction and an "on-again, off-again" sale, the phrase used by the public-radio reporter covering it, whose closing date was pushed back three times before finally completing on January 27, 2017. The buyer, Bill "Billy" Burns, an engineer from the Youngstown area, paid just over $1.1 million. Carroll County commission board president Jeff Ohler called it "one of the major items that we needed to cross off our bucket list." Burns kept the lodge building largely as it was and turned it into The Bluffs, a drug and alcohol treatment center. In 2016 MWCD bought back nearly 420 acres of the former resort golf course. A 1977 federal environmental impact statement had already called Atwood Lodge, with its golf courses, lighted tennis courts and ski slope, "a major revenue source".

A lake that ran dry enough to strand boats

In September 2024, water in Atwood Lake dropped low enough that MWCD told boat owners at some marinas to prepare to haul their vessels out entirely. Marina owner Neil Beavers, describing himself as third-generation on the lake, put it bluntly: "this is the worst I've seen it". Public suspicion fell on MWCD's water sales to oil and gas operators, but MWCD director Craig Butler's own numbers pushed back: the lake holds roughly 7 billion gallons, the sales contract capped withdrawals at 60 million gallons over 30 days, and the measurable effect, he said, was "a really negligible, less than an inch" of level change. Sales were cut and then halted anyway, weeks before the story broke, while the drought itself kept going.

A conservancy court of judges and a farmer-novelist's endorsement

A mid-1950s magazine feature in the library's MWCD files quotes Louis Bromfield, the Pulitzer-winning novelist-farmer whose Malabar Farm sits beside Pleasant Hill Lake and who had watched the district grow up "practically from his front porch": "I live in the garden spot of the world and I am glad... Fortunately for us we have the Muskingum Conservancy District right at our doorstep." The same piece describes MWCD as created by "a conservancy court consisting of one Common Pleas judge from each of the 14 counties" it covers, an agency of local government that received no tax income. Of the district's $377,538 income in 1953, 53.5 percent came from recreation: park admissions, concessions, cottage and club sites, boating permits, cabin rentals and the Division of Wildlife lease.

The lake since

Atwood is operated with Bolivar Dam and Leesville Lake as an integral unit of the Dover system: when Dover's outflow is held under 3,000 cubic feet per second and its pool is rising, Atwood cuts its own release to the minimum. When the pool reaches 935 feet, parts of the Dellroy boat dock and the MWCD camping area flood and stretches of county roads 29 and 93 are cut off. A 1946 sedimentation survey estimated the conservation pool would take roughly 1,216 years to fill at the observed rate, the slowest-silting figure of any Muskingum lake surveyed. By the mid-1970s Atwood and Charles Mill were the system's two heaviest-use lakes: Atwood drew 1,231,200 visitors in 1974, second only to Pleasant Hill's 1,236,200, and took in $1,411,861 in recreation receipts, the most of any project. In 2022 MWCD estimated Atwood's attendance at 1,011,927, the most of any MWCD lake, and Atwood Lake Park brought in $3,170,026.

The district keeps building. In 2022 it opened the 1.34-mile, $635,000 Cemetery Bay Trail, linking the Big Spring trailhead on State Route 542 to the park's trails for a 6.54-mile route. The same year a $29,700 project removed 830 cubic yards of sediment from the Atwood Lake Village cottage area, where boats could no longer reach some docks. In 2014 an MWCD study found the flood-storage capacity of its lakes had been reduced by about 25 percent, and Atwood stood fifth on the district's dredging priority list. Plans for 2026 and 2027 include treehouse cabins and a 1.7-mile Atwood Lake Dam Connector Trail to the dam's day-use area, along with an 18-lot cottage development on State Route 542.

Oil and gas are older here than many visitors know. MWCD's executive director wrote in 2014 that the district had produced oil and gas since its formation in 1933 and that there were 42 existing wells at Atwood Lake on MWCD land, with well pads placed to stay out of public view. In 2022 oil and gas brought MWCD $41,551,029 in revenue, against $5,858,263 from its maintenance assessment, an assessment the board cut by 50 percent in 2015 and by 66 percent in April 2023.

The dam has never come close to its 941-foot spillway crest. The Corps' water control manual reconstructs pools of 936.4 feet for the flood of March 1913 and 933.3 feet for August 1935, both before the dam existed, and 935.9 feet for January 1937, while it was under construction; the highest observed peak in the manual is 933.16 feet in January 1959. The largest flow at the damsite on record in 1975 was 3,540 cubic feet per second, on January 22, 1959. The highest pool observed by the USGS gauge since 2015 is 934.66 feet, on April 6, 2026, and the low is 915.05 feet, on November 28, 2016, well below the 923-foot winter pool. The severest drought on record for the Atwood basin struck in 1930-31, and the most recent the manual lists was 1988. The manual is blunt about drought planning: "the lake operation does not include plans for drought," and any water held for later release needs an approved deviation from normal regulation.

Federal dam-safety records classify Atwood as a high-hazard-potential structure, meaning a failure could cause loss of life downstream, and list its status as of late 2025 as under investigation, planning, permitting or design for remediation.

The water

The Atwood Regional Water and Sewer District, established in 1970, serves about 3,550 people over 22 square miles in eastern Warren Township and parts of Monroe, Orange, Harrison and Rose townships around the lake.

The lake sits on the Indian Fork of Conotton Creek, a tributary of the Tuscarawas River in the Muskingum basin, draining 70 square miles. Federal reviewers in 1977 rated surface waters in and around Leesville and Atwood lakes as good, while noting that stratification with low-oxygen bottom water does occur at Atwood. Samples taken in September 1974 found dissolved oxygen of 8.3 milligrams per liter at the surface but 0.2 at 34 feet down. In 2014 USGS began building a monitoring network at Atwood and five other MWCD lakes to track lake levels and detect oil and gas wastewater, and MWCD and USGS were testing a "Nowcast" program to estimate bacteria at swimming beaches at Atwood, Seneca and Tappan.

MWCD lists bluegill, bullheads, channel catfish, crappie, largemouth bass, northern pike, saugeye and yellow perch in the lake. In 2021 the Ohio Division of Wildlife called Atwood "a hotspot in northeast Ohio" for sheer numbers of saugeye: recent surveys showed adult abundance twice the regional and statewide averages, with more than half the fish 15 to 18 inches long. The state's fishing map, revised in 2010 from a 1999 survey, shows depths to about 30 feet at a summer pool of 928 feet.

The U.S. Geological Survey has gauged Atwood's pool elevation directly since November 2015, in cooperation with MWCD, and its tailwater gauge on Indian Fork below the dam keeps annual peak-flow records reaching back to 1939; the largest outflow on record is 1,610 cubic feet per second, on April 7, 1945.

Sources

Fishing and depth maps

Free PDF maps of Atwood Lake with depth contours, ramps and docks, each credited to the agency that published it. Not for navigation.

  • Atwood Lake Fishing Map Muskingum Watershed Conservancy District, lake last surveyed 1999, map revised 2010 · PDF, 0.9 MB
  • Atwood Lake Ohio Department of Natural Resources, lake last surveyed 1999, map revised 2010 · PDF, 0.9 MB

Timeline

37 dated newspaper stories, reports and records about Atwood Lake, 1834 to 2026, each linked to its source.

Show all 37
  1. Atwood (then unplatted) recorded as 'a thriving village' United Presbyterian Church baptismal records, via Atwood Village Historical Mark
  2. Atwood post office opens Ohio Ghost Town Exploration Co.
  3. The Great Flood of 1913 Muskingum Watershed Conservancy District
  4. The 1930 drought broadens the district's original flood-only mission MWCD magazine feature, via Ohio Memory vertical file
  5. Construction begins on Atwood Dam Wikipedia, citing GNIS/MWCD
  6. Atwood village abandoned (per this source's dating) Flickr user 'historydetective'
  7. Judge Frank F. Cope launches the first sailboat on Atwood Lake yourohionews.com, 75th regatta preview
  8. Sedimentation survey: Atwood's conservation pool projected to take 1,216 years to fill 1977 USACE Muskingum Basin Final EIS, via the Tappan-lane shared document
  9. Atwood Yacht Club incorporated Atwood Yacht Club
  10. First Atwood Harvest Moon Regatta held yourohionews.com
  11. Atwood Lodge built by the conservancy district search-engine summary
  12. Atwood Lake photographs (Sites and Scenes Around Ohio Collection) Ohio Department of Transportation, via Ohio Memory / Ohio History Connection
  13. Water Resources Development by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers in Ohio (1971 report) U.S. Army Corps of Engineers
  14. Roughness characteristics of natural channels -- Indian Fork below Atwood Dam gaging site USGS Water-Supply Paper 1849
  15. 1988 drought cited as the historical comparison point for low lake levels WJER Radio
  16. MWCD Annual Report of Operations, 2003 ('Commitment to the Future') Muskingum Watershed Conservancy District
  17. MWCD Annual Report of Operations, 2004 Muskingum Watershed Conservancy District
  18. MWCD Annual Report of Operations, 2005 Muskingum Watershed Conservancy District
  19. MWCD Annual Report of Operations, 2010 Muskingum Watershed Conservancy District
  20. MWCD Annual Report of Operations, 2015 -- Atwood Welcome Center and Trail Phase I Muskingum Watershed Conservancy District
  21. MWCD Annual Report of Operations, 2016 -- 'Welcome! The New Atwood Welcome Center' Muskingum Watershed Conservancy District
  22. Atwood Lake Resort sold for $1.1M at auction Club + Resort Business
  23. MWCD Annual Report of Operations, 2017 Muskingum Watershed Conservancy District
  24. MWCD Annual Report of Operations, 2022 -- new Bay Trail Muskingum Watershed Conservancy District
  25. Bridge over Atwood Lake to be replaced soon WHBC News-Talk 1480
  26. Atwood Lake in Carroll County drying up: boaters stranded, questions arise Cleveland 19 News
  27. Atwood Area Fall Festival returns Oct. 3-5 with crafts, food and live entertainment yourohionews.com
  28. Amish mother charged with murder after husband, son drown at Atwood Lake Cleveland 19 News / WKYC
  29. Carrollton woman, 83, plunges at Atwood Lake for American Cancer Society yourohionews.com
  30. Muskingum Watershed updates Carroll County on Atwood Lake projects, $25.5M budget yourohionews.com
  31. Atwood Lake boat parade set for July 4 near Dellroy as part of America 250 yourohionews.com
  32. Atwood Area Fall Festival photo contest set for Oct. 2-4 at Atwood Lake Park yourohionews.com
  33. Rising lake levels close roads across Carroll County -- Atwood and Leesville affected yourohionews.com
  34. Amish mom found not guilty by reason of insanity in drowning death of 4-year-old, returns to court Cleveland 19 News
  35. Flooding persists as lake levels drop slowly across Carroll County yourohionews.com
  36. MWCD unveils new cottage site development at Atwood Lake WJER Radio
  37. MWCD board to hold special meeting June 12 on Windward Shores lease rates at Atwood Lake yourohionews.com

Towns and ZIP codes around Atwood Lake

Water, health, jobs and history for the places on the shores and just downstream.

Towns

ZIP codes

Questions

When was Atwood Lake built?

Work began on August 12, 1935, under a contract with the W. L. Johnson Construction Company of Hicksville, Ohio, and the federal record says the dam was completed in September 1936 at a cost of $1,403,900. Change orders pushed the contract's final completion date to September 23, 1937, the same year a 1986 MWCD fact card gives.

What's under Atwood Lake?

The unplatted village of Atwood, once home to a post office, two general stores, a cooperage, a creamery and a school, lies under the lake near the dam, along with about five and a half miles of the old Wheeling & Lake Erie Carrollton branch between Atwood and Dellroy. A cluster of nine named farms south of New Cumberland, mapped in an 1875 county atlas, sat directly on Indian Fork in the stream corridor the reservoir now floods.

Who built Atwood Dam and why?

The U.S. Army Corps of Engineers built it for the Muskingum Watershed Conservancy District, part of a 14-dam system planned after the March 1913 flood and funded under a 1934 federal contract. The Flood Control Act of 1939 authorized transfer of the dams to the United States, so the Corps owns and operates the dam for flood control while MWCD owns and manages the lake and its land.

How big is Atwood Lake?

Normal pool covers 1,540 acres at elevation 928 feet, with 28 miles of shoreline; the flood pool can reach 2,460 acres at the 941-foot spillway crest. The dam is 65 feet high and 3,700 feet long, impounding up to 49,700 acre-feet at maximum flood-control pool. A 2010 state fishing map, based on a 1999 survey, gives 1,562 acres and 28.4 miles of shoreline.

Were any towns flooded by Atwood Lake besides Atwood village?

No. Dellroy and New Cumberland sit on the lake's perimeter and predate the reservoir; neither was inundated. Atwood village, which the lake and dam are named for, was the only community taken, though farms in Monroe Township went to the district through court appropriation cases.

Is Atwood Dam safe today?

Federal inspection records list Atwood as a high-hazard-potential dam, a rating that describes what failure would mean downstream rather than the dam's condition, and as of late 2025 they listed its status as under investigation, planning, permitting, or design for remediation by the Corps of Engineers.

Who were the landowners in the Atwood appropriation cases?

In April 1938 a Carroll County jury awarded Charles Creamer of Monroe Township $3,530 for land in the Atwood dam district that the district had appraised at $1,967. In a similar case John Day of Monroe Township took an agreed verdict of $3,875 for 39 acres, damage to his remaining 81 acres and a flood easement.

What fish are in Atwood Lake?

MWCD lists bluegill, bullheads, channel catfish, crappie, largemouth bass, northern pike, saugeye and yellow perch. In 2021 the Ohio Division of Wildlife called Atwood a northeast Ohio saugeye hotspot, with recent surveys showing adult abundance twice the regional and statewide averages.

Is there oil and gas drilling at Atwood Lake?

Yes, and long before the shale boom. MWCD's executive director wrote in 2014 that there were 42 existing wells at Atwood Lake on MWCD land, part of oil and gas production the district has carried on since it was formed in 1933.

More Ohio lakes

See them all

Cite this page

Cite this page as:

Cracked Buckeye, "Atwood Lake", https://crackedbuckeye.com/lakes/atwood/, built 2026-11-16, accessed [date].

How to cite · Report a correction · Built 2026-11-16