Ohio lakes · Fairfield County, Licking County, Perry County
Buckeye Lake
Ohio flooded a swamp in the 1820s to feed a canal; by the 1940s Buckeye Lake drew 50,000 visitors a day, then nearly lost its dam to 350-plus houses built on it.
- Built 1832
- 2,800 acres
- South Fork of the Licking River
- Ohio Department of Natural Resources
- Published , updated
Buckeye Lake right now
Summer temperature by depth
Only 2 summer temperature profiles with depth have been found for Buckeye Lake (1975-1978), too few to say what is typical.
Past measurements, not live readings: USGS Ohio Water Science Center, 4 profiles 1975-1978. From the Water Quality Portal, the EPA National Lakes Assessment and the Army Corps' lake records.
At a glance
Before the lake
Before the canal era, the area now under Buckeye Lake was a large swamp straddling the drainage divide between the Scioto and Muskingum watersheds, locally known as "Buffalo Swamp" or "the Big Swamp", a name the on-site marker attributes to Ohio Company explorer Christopher Gist in 1751. The swamp sat at the highest point between the Scioto and Licking rivers, which is exactly why the state later chose it as a canal feeder site.
The canal engineers left the best description of what the reservoir drowned. Their third annual report describes an "extensive marsh" beginning about a mile northeast of the summit and running east about eight miles, a quarter to half a mile wide, with a chain of ponds down its center, the longest of them a little over a mile. The same report says the marsh drained through three short outlets into the South Fork of the Licking, and that in floods the Licking ran backward through those channels into the marsh, leaving much of it under two or three feet of water. The engineers also eyed a second site, Bloody Run swamp, "near 1000 acres," two miles northwest of the summit.
In 1801 federal surveyor Elnathan Schofield mapped the area for 640-acre land grants to Canadian and Nova Scotian refugees of the Revolutionary War, measuring the pre-dam swamp at roughly 5 miles long and 400-500 yards across, far smaller than the reservoir that followed. That "Refugee land" survey still described the farms the state paid for a decade later, as the Minthorne award below shows.
One account, not independently confirmed by a second source, describes an ancient stone mound near the dam site, its base 182 feet across and at least 57 feet tall, that was quarried for dam construction material in 1831-32: 75 teams reportedly hauled some 15,000 wagon loads of stone from it over two years, destroying it along with sixteen smaller mounds around its base. Farmers digging into one of the smaller mounds in 1850 found a wood-slab burial.
Building the dam
Ohio authorized the Ohio and Erie Canal in February 1825, and ground was broken on July 4, 1825. The canal needed a dependable water supply at its highest point, so the state dammed the swamp to create the Licking Summit Reservoir, blocking drainage into the South Fork of the Licking River. The plan, as the commissioners laid it out, was to raise an embankment "across the out lets and along the low grounds" on the marsh's western edge, about a mile and a half of it built independently of the canal, six to ten feet high, of "gravel mixed with loam and clay." Filled to an average depth of eight feet, they figured, it would hold nearly 700 million cubic feet, and after evaporation still release 3,000 cubic feet a minute through 120 days of dry season.
The work moved fast. Bids for the whole summit level were taken on June 17, 1825, and the commissioners' December 1825 report records that the embankment for the reservoir, "two miles and twenty-three chains in length," went under contract with the rest of the summit; afterward they ordered a wall of timber set in the center of the bank for greater security. By their December 1826 report the "great reservoir" was not entirely finished but "in readiness to receive the streams destined to fill it". They had made the embankment heavier, higher and about eighteen chains longer than first planned, adding more than 60,000 cubic yards of earth, and built in a waste weir, a flood gate that could draw the reservoir to the bottom, and a feeder lock into the canal. On September 5, 1826, they let the contract for a feeder "six miles and forty-three chains" long from the south branch of the Licking to the reservoir.
The state's own 1912 official plat map, printed by the Board of Public Works, records that construction "was commenced in 1828 and completed in 1832 by the addition of 500 acres at the west end of the reservoir and called the 'New Reservoir.'" The National Inventory of Dams also gives 1832, while the 1912 map note and the 2002 lake marker give different start years (1828 and 1826). The commissioners' contemporary reports show that the main embankment went up in 1825-26, so the 1828 start on the 1912 map does not match them; 1832 is best read as the year the New Reservoir enlargement finished the job. We previously treated 1828-1832 as the main construction span; corrected October 2026.
A 2021 Ohio EPA-approved watershed plan explains that the original dam held too little water to operate the canal, so the impoundment was enlarged and a feeder channel built to divert water from the South Fork Licking River. The commissioners' reports show the feeder was part of the plan from the start, put under contract in 1826 as noted above, so the enlargement and the feeder were not one later project. That ditch survives today as the Reservoir Feeder, still an estimated 23% of the lake's annual phosphorus load. The 1912 map adds that the reservoir fed the canal "between Little Walnut Creek and Lockbourne, a distance of 31 miles", and that its original estimated area of 2,000 acres had grown to "not over 3,136 acres" if adjacent owners' claims were admitted.
Who was paid for the land
The page used to say that no 1820s land-acquisition record had been located. One has now. The canal commissioners' report of January 1828 says a board of appraisers, John Leist of Fairfield County, Daniel Converse of Muskingum and Joseph Ridgway of Franklin, assessed claims for "the canal, reservoir and feeder on the Licking summit level" at $1,223, "chiefly on account of land occupied by the reservoir, timber taken for securing the bank and making waste and feeder gates." The appendix lists the same $1,223 as schedule C, beside $2,687 allowed north of the Portage Summit, for a grand total of $8,921.64 that year. The individual names in that schedule are not printed in the 1828 compilation.
One name survives elsewhere. A 1930 Ohio Attorney General opinion recites that Thomas Minthorne was awarded $280 in damages for his farm in Range 18, Township 17, Section 22 of the Refugee lands, covering land inside the reservoir, land used for embankment and a 40-foot strip for a ditch. On February 16, 1839, appraisers awarded him a further $60 for a one-acre lot where the "New Reservoir" embankment met the canal, the site of the lock-tender's house.
The 1912, 1920 and 1922 state plat surveys of the lake's shoreline record landowner names decades later: Swisher, Davis, Bound's Heirs, Crane, Fickle Heirs, Zollinger, W. Murphy (153.67 acres), Hummel Heirs, Alspach, Neel and dozens more, along with platted resort communities and islands including Charleston, Lewis, Keller and Crane. These are 1912-1922 shoreline owners, not confirmed original 1820s grantees.
When the reservoir was impounded, a 50-acre segment of the bog mat stretched like "a giant waterlogged sponge" and rose 8 feet rather than submerging, becoming Cranberry Bog (see Stories, below). By 1894, with canal traffic fading against the railroads, the Ohio General Assembly reserved the reservoir as a public park "to be known by the name of 'Buckeye Lake'" by an act passed May 21, 1894, an idea championed, the yacht club's history says, by former Canal Superintendent George Watkins.
Stories
Cranberry Bog, a floating island older than the state park
Cranberry Bog is a floating mat of sphagnum moss, now about 8 acres, down from 50 or more, that has ridden on the lake's surface since the lake was impounded. ODNR explains why: as water backed up behind the dike, the rest of the swamp drowned, but the youngest, most buoyant part of the bog mat floated free, so that "now the lake surrounds the bog mat, a unique situation." It carries carnivorous round-leaved sundew and pitcher plants, orchids and the cranberry vines that give it its name, left behind by the retreat of the Wisconsin glaciation, and the same source warns that "eventually Cranberry Island will disappear." It is a registered National Natural Landmark and an Ohio State Nature Preserve; visitors need an access permit from ODNR's Division of Natural Areas and Preserves.
The 1922 tornado
On June 12, 1922, a tornado struck Buckeye Lake park directly. The next morning's Democratic Banner reported a search underway for bodies believed buried in the storm-swept park; at least three Columbus-area residents died, Myron B. Hill, Mrs. William H. Wohrle, and M. Scigler, with a fourth, Olive Beau of Newark, reported missing, and seven small boats missing on the lake. Damage was estimated at $100,000. A same-day Cleveland Czech-language paper, Svet, instead reported ten people killed when a dressing house collapsed. The two death tolls have never been reconciled against a confirmed final count.
The 1924 Colored Day drowning
On August 8, 1924, during the Muskingum Valley Colored Elks #82's annual "Colored Day" celebration, the pier dance hall at the Lake Breeze Hotel collapsed when its pilings gave way, dropping dancers into the water and drowning seven people, according to a period newspaper account reproduced by a local-history page; Coasterpedia also records seven deaths. Officially ruled accidental, the event has been persistently rumored locally to be connected to Klan activity, given its timing squarely between the two Klan rallies described below, though no source offers physical evidence for that connection.
The Klan at the lake
Buckeye Lake hosted two of the largest Ku Klux Klan "Konclaves" in U.S. history, in 1923 and 1925, the second billed at the time as the "largest Konclave in the United States", with claimed crowds near 100,000 that the yacht club's history calls probably exaggerated. Both were organized in part by D.C. Stephenson, the Indiana Klan's "Grand Dragon," who kept a summer home at the lake and was later convicted of second-degree murder in Indiana. National Klan speakers addressed crowds at the lake, Klan weddings were performed on its shores, and the interurban ran special cars to ferry attendees.
The amusement park's rise and uncertain fall
The resort was a railway's creation. The Columbus, Buckeye Lake and Newark Traction Company brought excursionists by interurban from 1904 to 1929 to a nine-acre "electric park" with free daily admission, hotels and cottages on leased ground. The company's 1902 promotional booklet says it already owned "some thirty-three acres at the end of the Electric line" and leased three miles of lake frontage. By 1911, the park marker says, there were two dance pavilions, a beach and bathhouse, an arcade, a ballpark and power-boat races. On July 4, 1921, the Newark Leader counted 55,000 visitors, more than on any day "since the opening of this popular resort."
A ferris wheel and spinning rides came in the 1920s, and work began on the "Dips" roller coaster at the end of that decade. The park also had a 100-by-200-foot swimming pool and a roller rink. The Crystal Ballroom became "one of Ohio's premier entertainment venues in the 1930s", and at the park's 1940s peak as many as 50,000 visitors came in a day while the Crystal Pool staged water shows by Hollywood celebrities. The marker at the old park records that Guy Lombardo, Glenn Miller and "Tommy Dorsey with his singer Frank Sinatra" played the Crystal Ballroom and the Lake Breeze Pier Ballroom, and the park's own marker adds Louis Armstrong. The Newark papers show the bookings: Kay Kyser's orchestra at Danceland in July 1941, Guy Lombardo and His Royal Canadians on August 27, 1941, Eddie Duchin that September 14, and a Miss Ohio contest feeding the Miss America pageant at the Crystal Danceteria in August 1940. The lake became a state park in 1949, with the creation of ODNR.
Sources disagree on when it ended: a tourism history says the park closed in 1970, but two on-site historical markers instead describe the resort as having "operated until the mid 1960s" or having "declined in the 1960s". Today only the fountain survives, in the state park's parking lot.
The lake since
The lake's dam nearly failed in the 21st century. In March 2015 an Army Corps of Engineers review found the 180-year-old, 4.1-mile Class I embankment at risk of "imminent catastrophic failure", not from age alone but because more than 350 houses, plus docks and foundations, had been built on and into it. The Corps said officials should immediately replace the dam or drain the reservoir, and that a failure could endanger 3,000 people. Its report recommended draining the lake until repairs could be made. Nearly 500 residents and business owners packed a public meeting asking that the lake be refilled deeper; officials instead held it at the lower winter level. The state committed $150 million, and work began in September 2015, running 18 to 20 hours a day, seven days a week, by WOSU's account.
The fix was a soil-mix cutoff wall forming a standalone gravity dam upstream of the existing embankment, "likely one of a kind in the United States," so the new structure would not depend on the old one. Phase 1, a 30-foot-wide, 4.1-mile stability berm built of nearly 382,000 cubic yards of local bank material, finished in May 2016, "almost one year ahead of schedule". ASI Constructors built it, Gannett Fleming designed it, and a plaque at the park credits both with Michael Baker International. The project was complete by November 2018 at a final cost of $107 million, done in three years (construction-trade coverage cites $110 million), well under the $150 million set aside. It won the 2019 National Dam Rehabilitation Project of the Year award and is the largest capital-improvements project in ODNR's 70-year history. A paved trail now runs atop the dam; the group Bike Buckeye Lake formed in 2015 to get it added to the plan.
The rebuild changed life on the shore. By spring 2017, with the lake back to about a foot below normal, residents had been made to tear out private docks, and four miles of chain-link fence ran along the work zone. One 30-year resident said her property was no longer waterfront and had lost so much value she could not afford to sell; the owner of the Island House cut his serving staff from 15 to four. A marina owner, by contrast, said boat sales had doubled from the year before.
Water quality has been a persistent, separate problem. Buckeye Lake has been "regularly experiencing algal blooms since 2010", driven mainly by farm runoff. The Reservoir Feeder alone supplies roughly 23% of the lake's phosphorus from an 11,024-acre watershed that is 61% row crops, and the Millersport sewage plant about 1.3%; that 2021 plan builds on Buckeye Lake for Tomorrow's 2013 Nutrient Reduction Plan and targets streambank erosion, failing septic systems and farm runoff. In January 2023 the University of Toledo reported the lake was "enjoying its best water quality in years," while cautioning that blooms remain a threat.
The water
Buckeye Lake is not used as a public drinking-water source. The Village of Buckeye Lake buys its water from the Millersport treatment plant, which draws on four wells tapping an aquifer about 75 feet down beneath roughly 70 feet of clay, sand and gravel. So the lake's algal-bloom problems are a recreation, ecology and fish-kill issue rather than a drinking-water-treatment one for the two nearest villages.
The lake averages only about 5 feet deep, by the 2013 Nutrient Reduction Plan's count, a major driver of its bloom-prone condition. It sits at the bottom of two HUC-12 subwatersheds draining to the South Fork Licking River, the same stream the original dike was built to block. The H2Ohio-funded Brooks Park wetland, a 3-acre, $700,000 project on Murphy's Run, a south-shore tributary, aims to keep up to 1,620 pounds of nitrogen, 784 pounds of phosphorus and 437 tons of sediment a year out of the lake.
Sources
- Public documents concerning the Ohio canals (Kilbourn, 1828): canal commissioners' annual reports, Internet Archive
- Map of Buckeye Lake, Board of Public Works of Ohio, 1912, Ohio Memory
- Ohio Attorney General Opinion 1930-1853 (Minthorne awards)
- National Inventory of Dams, OH00474
- Buckeye Lake marker, HMdb
- Buckeye Lake Park marker, HMdb
- Buckeye Lake Amusement Park marker, HMdb
- Buckeye Lake Dam plaque, HMdb
- Cranberry Bog State Nature Preserve, ODNR
- Buckeye Lake State Park, ODNR
- Sketch of scenes along the Columbus, Buckeye Lake and Newark traction railway, 1902, Internet Archive
- Newark Leader, July 8, 1921, Chronicling America
- Democratic Banner, June 13, 1922, Chronicling America
- Lost Columbus: Relive Buckeye Lake's Heyday, Columbus Monthly
- From Great Swamp to Great Destination, Escape to Buckeye Lake
- How Buckeye Lake Came to Be, Buckeye Lake Yacht Club
- When The Klan Came to the Lake, Buckeye Lake Yacht Club
- Madge Oberholtzer: the murder that brought down the Ku Klux Klan, WCPO
- Hundreds attend Buckeye Lake meeting after faulty dam report, WCBE, 2015
- Corps: Buckeye Lake dam could fail, Outdoor News, 2015
- $150 million dam construction project begins at Buckeye Lake, WOSU, 2015
- Buckeye Lake Dam Improvements, damsafety.org
- ASI Continues $110M Rebuild of Buckeye Lake Dam, Construction Equipment Guide
- Buckeye Lake Reopens Its Waters, WOSU, 2017
- Bike Buckeye Lake
- Buckeye Lake Reservoir Feeder Nine-Element Plan, Ohio EPA, 2021
- Buckeye Lake Nutrient Reduction Plan, 2013, Ohio EPA
- H2Ohio initiative creates wetland in Buckeye Lake, Farm and Dairy, 2021
- Village of Buckeye Lake 2025 Consumer Confidence Report
- Buckeye Lake Enjoying Best Water Quality in Years, UToledo News
- The Horrible History of Buckeye Lake, Steven Outside blog
- Buckeye Lake's Floating Cranberry Island, LakeScientist
Fishing and depth maps
Free PDF maps of Buckeye Lake with depth contours, ramps and docks, each credited to the agency that published it. Not for navigation.
- Buckeye Lake Ohio Department of Natural Resources, lake last surveyed 1998, map revised 2014 · PDF, 2.1 MB
Timeline
80 dated newspaper stories, reports and records about Buckeye Lake, 1908 to 2023, each linked to its source.
Show all 80
- Local personals: Dr. M. H. Sherrington spent Sunday at Buckeye Lake The Democrat-Sentinel
- Baptists Decide Upon Summerland Beach As the Site For the Assembly Meetings of the Future The Democratic Banner
- Girl Leaped to Her Death (auto accident returning from the Solinger cottage, Buckeye Lake) The Democratic Banner
- Advertisement: Visit Buckeye Lake Park, the finest pleasure ground in the Middle West Newark Leader
- News from Our Locals (Buckeye Lake mentioned in local-notices column) Newark Leader
- Pickpocketing reported at Buckeye Lake Park Newark Leader
- Buckeye Lake Visitors Stalled by bad road conditions Newark Leader
- Return From Buckeye Lake: Misses Mary Oakleaf, Helen Elizabeth and Julia Maier Newark Leader
- Lost pocketbook with $600 cash recovered at Buckeye Lake Park on Labor Day Newark Leader
- Buckeye Lake Brimming Full Newark Leader
- Storm report (Czech-language): ten people killed at Buckeye Lake park when a bathhouse/dressing building collapsed in a violent windstorm svět = world 1911-1939
- Mrs. William Gallagher entertains the U and I Club at her Buckeye Lake cottage Newark Leader
- New route accommodation for persons visiting Newark or Buckeye Lake Newark Leader
- Pier Ballroom Collapses Into the Lake -- Lake Breeze Hotel, Colored Elks No. 82 "Colored Day" period newspaper account, per Buckeye Lake Place local-history page
- Local personals: the Choguill and Devitt families spent Sunday at Buckeye Lake and Zanesville Morgan County Democrat
- Picnic at Buckeye Lake Park for Newark and Licking County school children Newark Leader
- Local personals: the Patterson and Grigsby families motored to Newark and visited Buckeye Lake Morgan County Democrat
- Local personals: the Van Valkenburgh and Mohr families leave for weeks at Buckeye Lake The Ironton News
- Local personals: the Hilaman family spent Sunday at Buckeye Lake Morgan County Democrat
- Fellowship Club names E. D. Perkins as Buckeye Lake chairman for next year's parties Newark Leader
- Beauty contest prizes to be awarded at Buckeye Lake Park July 25 Newark Leader
- Death notice: Albert Charles McCann, 54, died at his home on Renner Street, Buckeye Lake Newark Leader
- American Legion Day at Buckeye Lake Park Newark Leader
- Children's Home youngsters entertained at Buckeye Lake as guests of manager A. M. Brown Newark Leader
- Local personals: the Miller family attended the Maccabee picnic at Buckeye Lake Morgan County Democrat
- Advertisement: Spend Labor Day at Buckeye Lake Park Newark Leader
- Marjorie Swartz of Buckeye Lake wins girls balloon-blowing contest Newark Leader
- Car dealer advertisement naming Ernest O. Myer of Buckeye Lake Newark Leader
- Red Cross first-aid tents furnished to large gatherings at Buckeye Lake Newark Leader
- Advertisement: dancing at Avondale, Buckeye Lake, under new management Newark Leader
- New bus service, Newark-Hebron-Buckeye Lake, 15 round trips daily Newark Leader
- Advertisement: Kay Kyser's orchestra at Danceland, Buckeye Lake Park Newark Leader
- Barn Dance Headliners to Play Buckeye Lake Danceland Newark Leader
- Sixth Annual Outing and Field Day, Licking County Farmers and Sportsmen's Club, Set for Buckeye Lake Park Newark Leader
- Delta Chi Sigma Sorority Dinner at Gratziano's Inn, Buckeye Lake Newark Leader
- Cavalcade of America Labor Day finale: 125 Buckeye Lake park employees, Maurice W. Rice as Lincoln Newark Leader
- Eddie Duchin and his orchestra to play Danceland, Buckeye Lake park, Sept. 14 Newark Leader
- The Cavalcade of America -- Buckeye Lake Park Photos by Don Pound (Ulysses S. Grant portrayal) Newark Leader
- The Cavalcade of America -- Buckeye Lake Park Photos by Don Pound (John C. Pemberton portrayal) Newark Leader
- The Cavalcade of America -- Buckeye Lake Park Photos by Don Pound (George Gordon Meade portrayal) Newark Leader
- The Cavalcade of America -- Buckeye Lake Park Photos by Don Pound (series continues) Newark Leader
- The Cavalcade of America -- Buckeye Lake Park Photos by Don Pound (series continues, Thanksgiving issue) Newark Leader
- Buckeye Lake Park Opening: 1942 season opens May 22 under manager A. M. Brown Newark Leader
- Patriotic pageant United We Stand staged at Buckeye Lake park for American Legion Day Newark Leader
- Cavalcade of America Grand Finale, Buckeye Lake Park (125 employees, Lincoln and Uncle Sam portrayals) Newark Leader
- Local personals: Miss Joan Evans a guest at the Oliver cottage, Buckeye Lake The Union County Journal
- Local personals: afternoon spent at the Behrens cottage, Buckeye Lake The Union County Journal
- Feature on Ohio's first canal and the Licking Summit near Buckeye Lake The Union County Journal
- Local personals: friends visited at Buckeye Lake The Union County Journal
- Duck Hunters Report Good Hunting at Buckeye Lake: fair kill of Teal, Mallard and Black ducks The Oakwood Press
- Postal Auxiliary Plans Buckeye Lake Meeting West Side News
- Local personals: the Meighen family spent Sunday at Buckeye Lake The Journal
- Local personals: the Spires family of Buckeye Lake calling on neighbors The Journal
- Local Family Takes Part In Outing At Buckeye Lake Over The Weekend West Side News
- Business directory: Central Ohio Federal Savings branch, Buckeye Lake at Park Entrance The Catholic Times
- Business directory: New System Bakery, Buckeye Lake The Catholic Times
- Real estate: cottage for sale/wanted at Buckeye Lake, Loudermilk Realty Co. West Side News
- Business directory: Buckeye Lake window company listing The Catholic Times
- Funeral notice naming Charles Ray of Buckeye Lake among mourners The Journal
- Feature on the patchwork of boat-license rules across Ohio's lakes, including Buckeye Lake Eastern Review
- Diocesan clergy list: Fr. Thomas J. Lowery, Our Lady of Mt. Carmel, Buckeye Lake The Catholic Times
- Advertisement: Buckeye Marina Inc., west end of Buckeye Lake, new building in Millersport Eastern Review
- Book review by Fr. James J. McEwan, pastor of Our Lady of Mt. Carmel Church, Buckeye Lake The Catholic Times
- Fr. James McEwan of Our Lady of Mount Carmel, Buckeye Lake, to lead pilgrimage to Oberammergau The Catholic Times
- Advertisement: Smitty's U-Drive-It Boat Line, Buckeye Lake Park (repeat) Eastern Review
- Buckeye Lake Has Trophy Sized Bass Fishing Eastern Review
- Bowman Dairy Days promotion at Buckeye Lake Park, July 26-28 Eastern Review
- Bowman Dairy anniversary: free rides at Buckeye Lake park for three days Eastern Review
- Advertisement: Crab Baker outboard motors, Buckeye Lake/Hebron Johnson dealer Eastern Review
- Buckeye Lake for Tomorrow incorporated to improve watershed water quality Buckeye Lake for Tomorrow, Inc.
- Bike Buckeye Lake formed, advocates successfully for a multipurpose trail atop the rebuilt dam Bike Buckeye Lake
- Corps: Buckeye Lake dam could fail Outdoor News
- Problems At Buckeye Lake Dam Have Raised Questions About Dam Safety Across State WCBE
- ASI Continues $110M Rebuild of Buckeye Lake Dam Construction Equipment Guide
- Advisories issued for Ohio waterways Dayton Daily News
- Grateful residents still have questions The Columbus Dispatch
- People swimming in Buckeye Lake despite warnings for high levels of algae 10TV
- Until we eliminate toxic algae, warnings shouldn't be ignored The Columbus Dispatch
- Buckeye Lake Reservoir Feeder HUC-12 Nine-Element NPS-IS Plan approved Ohio EPA / Perry Soil and Water Conservation District
- Lost Columbus: Relive Buckeye Lake's Heyday as an Amusement Park and Stop for Famous Bands Columbus Monthly
Towns and ZIP codes around Buckeye Lake
Water, health, jobs and history for the places on the shores and just downstream.
Towns
ZIP codes
Questions
When was Buckeye Lake built?
The canal commissioners' own reports show the reservoir embankment was put under contract in 1825 and was ready to receive water by December 1826, with a feeder from the South Fork of the Licking contracted that September. The state's 1912 plat map instead says work began in 1828 and ended in 1832, when a 500-acre "New Reservoir" was added at the west end, and the National Inventory of Dams lists 1832. It was built as the Licking Summit Reservoir, a feeder for the Ohio and Erie Canal, and was renamed Buckeye Lake by the Ohio General Assembly on May 21, 1894.
What's under Buckeye Lake?
Before the dam, the site was a marsh known as Buffalo Swamp or the Big Swamp. The canal engineers described it as about eight miles long with a chain of ponds down its center. The 1912-1922 state plat surveys name shoreline landowners (Swisher, Davis, Zollinger, Murphy, Hummel Heirs and more), the platted town of Thornport, and islands including Crane, Lieb, Keller and Charleston. One unconfirmed account describes a large stone mound near the dam site, quarried away for construction material in 1831-32.
Why did Buckeye Lake's dam almost fail?
A 2015 Army Corps of Engineers review found the 4.1-mile earthen embankment at risk of imminent catastrophic failure, largely because more than 350 homes, plus docks and foundations, had been built on and into it over the preceding century. Ohio spent about $107 million on a new freestanding soil-mix dam, completed in November 2018.
Is Buckeye Lake safe to swim in?
The lake has had algal blooms regularly since 2010 and beaches are monitored for microcystin. Check current advisories before swimming; the lake's shallow depth (about 5 feet average) and heavily farmed watershed make blooms a recurring risk.
What happened to the Buckeye Lake amusement park?
The park grew from an interurban "electric park" that opened in 1904 into a full amusement park, peaking at up to 50,000 visitors a day in the 1940s with big bands playing the Crystal Ballroom and the Pier Ballroom. Tourism histories say it closed in 1970, though two historical markers say it had already declined by the mid-1960s. Only a fountain survives, in the state park parking lot.
What towns or events made Buckeye Lake infamous?
The lake hosted two of the largest Ku Klux Klan rallies in U.S. history in 1923 and 1925. In 1924, a pier dance hall collapsed during a Black community celebration, drowning seven people, an event still rumored locally to be connected to the Klan.