Ohio lakes · Mahoning County

Lake Milton

Youngstown built Lake Milton in the 1910s for its steel mills, drowning Fredericksburg; the lake was drained from 1986 to 1988.

  • Built 1916
  • 1,780 acres
  • Mahoning River
  • Ohio Department of Natural Resources, Division of Parks & Watercraft
  • Published , updated

Summer temperature by depth

Lake Milton stratifies in summer: a warm upper layer sits on colder water below, and the two barely mix until the fall turnover.

Across 29 deep-water summer profiles measured 1970-1981, the thermocline, where the water turns sharply colder, sat about 16 ft down (half of them between 12 and 21 ft). Surface water averaged 76 °F; the deepest readings, about 25 ft down, averaged 69 °F.

Below about 20 ft the water usually held less than 2 milligrams of oxygen per litre, too little for most fish, until the lake turned over in the fall.

0 ft 10 ft 20 ft 30 ft 65°F 70°F 75°F 80°F thermocline July August
Average water temperature at each depth in July and August, across every measured profile.

Past measurements, not live readings: U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, Pittsburgh District (data via USGS data release doi:10.5066/P9IRZL8S), 73 profiles 1970-1981; USGS Ohio Water Science Center, 2 profiles 1979. From the Water Quality Portal, the EPA National Lakes Assessment and the Army Corps' lake records.

At a glance

Before the lake

Milton Township, on the Mahoning River, was settled starting in 1803 by Nathaniel Stanley and Aaron Porter, who "followed the Mahoning River as far as was navigable", with the Van Netten family settling the township's west side. Early industry followed the river quickly: Jesse Holliday arrived in 1804 and built a grist mill, sawmill and carding mill, the grist mill two stories high, about 34 by 40 feet, with a 22-foot undershot wheel, followed by a linseed-oil plant, a flax mill and a woolen factory. The page earlier said "Jesse Halliday" ran taverns and a mill there in the late 1700s; both county sources give Holliday and 1804, corrected October 2026.

Fredericksburg, also called Frederick, was laid out by Frederick Byers, who came from Pennsylvania about 1824 and settled just west of the river; the village "is called by his first name." The 1882 county history remembers it as "a flourishing little village on the river, near the south line of the township", already reduced by then to a few dilapidated houses and a church "windowless and almost roofless." In its stagecoach days, when coaches from Pittsburgh and Cleveland passed through daily, it had three taverns open at once (Louis Lebaugh's, where the stage stopped, Moses Everett's and Frederick Myers's), a store Peter Kinnaman opened in 1834, a distillery run briefly by Dyer Fitch until "Mecca, or lubricating oil," got into the water and spoiled the liquor, a tannery, a hatter, a tailor and wagonmakers. Its post office was later moved to Berlin. The township's own history says the old stage stop now lies "beneath the waters of Lake Milton." The 1874 county atlas, read directly off the original Milton Township plate, shows Fredericksburg, labeled simply "Frederick," as a platted village of 31 numbered lots with a church, and names six lot-holders: W.J. Moore, A. Korney, W. Case, J. Shirey, G. Brown, and S. Westover.

The same atlas plate shows a second riverside settlement a few miles north, the crossroads called "Milton P.O.," almost certainly the place the township and the eventual lake took their name from. It had a woolen mill, a sawmill, and named residents including J.H. Feister, J. Delong, Chas Porter, J.M. Callender, and G. Ewing. Along the river's meander through the township, the same plate names nineteen farms directly on the corridor the reservoir would flood, among them Warren Craig (168 acres), John Scott (the largest single riverside holding at 357.87 acres), and the Forder and Carson family farms closest to the eventual dam site. A cemetery symbol is marked directly on Mahala Weisner's 91-acre parcel between Frederick and Milton P.O., the first documented pre-dam cemetery for this lake, though whether it was ever relocated is not known.

Pricetown took its name from Judge Robert Price, who owned the Holliday mills from about 1817; it had taverns, merchants, physicians, a post office from about 1808, and "had reached its best days by 1840." The modern USGS gauge for the lake is still named "Milton Reservoir near Pricetown", though it is not established whether the settlement itself was flooded or simply lent its name to the area.

Building the dam

The City of Youngstown began acquiring 3,416 acres along the Mahoning River in Milton Township in 1910, building a reservoir to supply and cool its iron and steel mills. The plan frightened people downstream from the start. In July 1912 the Alliance Review reported that Newton Falls was "taking on alarm," fearing that if the big Milton dam "ever is completed and breaks, the village is a goner".

Construction had not yet started when, on March 23-27, 1913, a four-day storm dropped 7-9 inches of rain across the Mahoning watershed as part of the statewide Great Flood of 1913. The river crested 23 feet above normal, 8 feet higher than any flood previously recorded, part of a disaster that hit 94 Ohio towns, destroyed 220 bridges, and killed an estimated 367-467 people statewide, throwing about 25,000 Youngstown-area steelworkers out of work as the mills flooded. The flood jump-started the dam project. Youngstown Sheet & Tube's own employee magazine put it plainly in October 1946: "In the spring of 1913 the Mahoning went on another rampage and water swept through the plant. Milton dam was built to prevent a similar occurrence and since then there has been no serious damage from floods."

That July the city's engineers and lawyers put the project at $751,000: $500,000 for the dam, $20,000 to clear the site, $141,000 for moving roads and building culverts and bridges, and $90,000 for land still to be bought. With $320,000 on hand, an ordinance for $431,000 in bonds went to council. A spring 1914 report described the reservoir's purpose: water "for use through the valley during the dry months of the year, when the natural flow of the stream is insufficient". Work was rough: in August 1914 an Austrian laborer on the dam was murdered and four men were arrested. In September 1916 Youngstown's mayor and service director said "nothing less than an earthquake" could prevent the dam's completion that year, with the final fill in the spillway going in and the banks being protected against wash. By October a Chagrin Falls paper described the finished work: a 2,800-foot dam of earth reinforced by concrete with a 635-foot spillway, a lake six and a half miles long covering 1,700 acres, every building and tree removed from the basin, at a cost of $1,100,000 and more than four years' work.

That puts completion in 1916, as the National Inventory of Dams and the Business Journal's history both say, while many later sources, including a 2017 "centennial" celebration, treat 1917 as the year the lake was created. The page earlier repeated a 2013 account of a dam finished in 1913; the 1914-1916 newspaper reports show it was still being built, corrected October 2026. J.W. LeDoux is the design consultant of record; no contractor name has been found, though a January 1914 local column reported the reservoir contractor unloading a large steam shovel.

The land taking

The city used juries when owners would not sell. In September 1911 Eva C. Shively and others, whom the city was suing to appropriate land for the reservoir, asked to move the trial out of Mahoning County, arguing they lived 20 miles from the county seat and most jurors would come from Youngstown, the city that wanted the water. In November 1913 a jury in Judge Robinson's court fixed the price of two tracts of F.H. and Myrtle Clark's farm, 19.6 acres for $1,304.66 and 39.5 acres for $2,900, roughly what the city had paid for other land nearby; a third tract on the same farm, owned by Mrs. Clark's mother, Mary J. Rose, went to the same jury.

By December 30, 1913, only 65 acres remained to be bought, and the city would own nearly 3,400 acres. Seventeen of those acres belonged to Youngstown capitalist Henry Wick, who held out because he said the land was underlaid with coal. In July 1915 council took up an ordinance to buy 17.47 acres of the Wick farm, the purchase that would "mean the end of negotiations to acquire land" for the reservoir. Families in Fredericksburg went too: ["farms and houses in Fredericktown [were] sold to the City of Youngstown as the dam was constructed and the river flooded and consumed Fredericktown."](https://businessjournaldaily.com/craig-beach-from-snack-shack-to-entertainment-mecca/) No full list of the families bought out has been found, and no county deed-index or city-council search has been completed for this lake.

Stories

Ward Craig and the dance hall that launched Dean Martin

Ward E. Craig, a schoolteacher born in Milton Township in 1872, came to watch the dam being built and around 1916 opened a refreshment stand for the crowds, "Craig's Landing," with swimming, snacks, music and boat docks. In 1920 he built a dance hall, and in 1922 he and investors formed the Craig Beach Co. to build an amusement park that by 1929 had a Ferris wheel, merry-go-round, pony rides and roller coaster, with about 500 rental cottages by the early 1930s. Cab Calloway played there, and in 1934 a 17-year-old Dino Crocetti made his stage debut "with the George Williams Orchestra at what was then the Craig Beach Dance Hall", singing "Oh Marie," years before he became Dean Martin. The park had its dark chapters too: it went bankrupt and was sold at sheriff's sale in 1934, and a 1941 roller-coaster accident killed two teenagers at an event that drew more than 20,000 people. The Village of Craig Beach was incorporated in 1931, and the amusement park closed in 1966, unable to compete with newer parks. Craig himself had sold out in the late 1920s, run bus lines out of Warren, and died in 1962 at 90.

The steelworkers came too. The Sheet & Tube Bulletin records a company picnic at Lake Milton on July 4, 1922, a 1923 photo taken "when the dam, a part of which can be seen in the background," had just been finished, and, decades later, a retired open-hearth man who "spends his summers at his cottage on Lake Milton". The water took lives early: Robert Donaldson, 18, of Cleveland drowned swimming in the lake in 1918, and Myrtle Stone, 25, drowned at the reservoir in 1921.

A lake that vanished for two years

The trouble began early. A 1928 report, just 12 years after completion, indicated possible instability; a 1969 report found "distress," a 1970 report "seepage," and in 1974 work began to anchor the wingwall. ODNR's Dam Safety Section, after inspections in the early 1970s, recommended a detailed structural analysis, and remedial work from 1975 added rock anchors to the spillway and a downstream berm to the embankment.

By the mid-1980s the dam was deemed dangerous, and the City of Youngstown, which owned the lake, decided it could not afford the millions of dollars in repairs. In March 1986 a photo caption on the Youngstown Business Journal's front page warned of a "dangerously weak right wingwall"; if the dam ruptured, "water would drown the city of Newton Falls five miles downstream". On March 3, 1986 state Sen. Harry Meshel announced $6.3 million in state funding, including $3.8 million moved from a planned reservoir in Green Township. That spring the gates were opened and the lake was drained down to a cracked, weedy mud flat. Business collapsed: a chamber survey expected a 30 to 50 percent drop in trade, Miller Marina reported business down 85 percent, and fishing was "next to nonexistent".

Two years of rebuilding later, the dam gates were ceremonially closed on March 31, 1988, and the lake began to refill, only to run straight into the historic 1988 national drought, leaving the lake only partially full through one more dry summer before boating and fishing fully returned in 1989 (Business Journal Daily). The City of Youngstown, "admitting that they could no longer maintain the dam," asked the state to take it over; ODNR agreed that fall, and Lake Milton was dedicated as Ohio's 72nd state park in 1988. After the refill the lake was stocked with muskies and largemouth and smallmouth bass, and anglers "flocked to the lake" for "some of the finest bass fishing Ohio has ever produced".

The lake that keeps getting fancier

A 2005-2007, $20 million water-and-sewer project reached much of the shoreline, and combined with low interest rates and pandemic-era demand for lake living, it set off a real building boom. Modest 1950s-60s cottages on lots that once fetched $150,000-175,000 gave way by 2021 to "mini McMansions" on $525,000 waterfront lots, with 15 zoning permits filed in the first four and a half months of that year alone and homes selling well past $1 million, a striking contrast with a Mahoning County median home price still under $125,000 (Tribune Chronicle; Vindicator archives).

The lake since

Lake Milton marked its "centennial" in August 2017 (counting from 1917) with a classic-car parade and nearly 50 watercraft in a parade led by a 41-foot catamaran houseboat, on what was then described as a 1,685-acre lake; the Lake Milton Boat Club, founded 1949, had 135 members at the time (Vindicator archives). That same month the body of Kyle Alspaugh, 29, of East Canton was recovered from the lake after a fisherman saw a boat moving erratically and heard cries for help; searchers used boats, drones, divers and helicopters.

In 2011, a Mahoning County property reappraisal drove the same boat club's assessed value from $583,900 to over $2 million, purely on lakefront land values (Vindicator archives). Lake Milton Brewery opened in 2020 in a former community center, and by 2025 billed itself as the area's only combined brewery, winery, seltzer maker and bourbon bar, with more than 65 bourbon and whiskey brands (Vindicator/vindy.com).

The dam still needs work. In 2016 the state committed more than $2 million to repairs of the earthen embankment, concrete spillway and lake drain, to bring the dam into compliance with Ohio dam-safety law; state Rep. John Boccieri called the lake "a crucial part of the Mahoning River's water infrastructure." The dam's current federal safety record lists its hazard classification as High and its condition, as of an April 2016 inspection, as Poor.

In March 2025, an ordinary winter gizzard-shad fish kill washed ashore near the Mahoning Avenue boat ramp; an Ohio Division of Wildlife biologist attributed it to routine late-winter oxygen depletion under ice, calling shad "the wimps of the fish world," with no cleanup planned (Vindicator/vindy.com).

The water

For over seventy years, from construction until 1986, Lake Milton belonged to the City of Youngstown and served as Youngstown's water supply in its early years, feeding and cooling the city's iron and steel mills on the Mahoning River downstream. The Army Corps ran it in tandem with its new Berlin Reservoir, 10 miles upstream. When Berlin filled in July 1943, its excess was discharged into "Milton Reservoir located immediately downstream," the two reaching 102,000 acre-feet of combined usable storage on July 12, and releases from the pair kept the river at Youngstown from warming much above 105 degrees that summer.

Today the lake is not the community's drinking water. The Jackson-Milton Metro Water District buys finished water from the City of Youngstown, drawn from the Mahoning Valley Sanitary District's Meander Creek Reservoir, and runs only a distribution system. The dam's authorized purposes still list water supply alongside recreation.

The drainage area covers 276 square miles on the Mahoning River, and per a 2025 fishing column, Lake Milton is "the oldest reservoir in the Mahoning River drainage", predating the federal Berlin, Mosquito Creek and West Branch (Kirwan) reservoirs built later elsewhere in the basin. The page earlier said those three were built downstream; Berlin is upstream, on the same river, and the other two are on tributaries, corrected October 2026.

No Ohio EPA or Ohio Department of Health harmful-algal-bloom advisory specific to the lake has been documented; ODNR points swimmers to the state's BeachGuard advisories for the 600-foot beach. The 1988-89 refill after the two-year drawdown is credited with creating strong young-fish habitat, as new-growth trees and grasses drowned in the rising water. ODNR lists walleye, largemouth bass, bluegill, crappie and channel catfish, with smallmouth bass, brown bullhead, yellow perch, white bass and muskellunge; a 2022 state fishing forecast called its smallmouth population "abundant," with "a sizable batch of fish in the 12- to 15-inch range".

The USGS gauge record from 2016 to 2026 shows a striking, consistent annual pattern: the lake is drawn down to roughly 938.9-939.4 feet every winter from a normal summer pool near 948.5-949.3 feet, with a record high of 949.34 feet on May 31, 2019. That matches ODNR's schedule: the fall drawdown typically begins October 15, refilling starts March 15, and the lake drops about 8 feet in winter.

Sources

Fishing and depth maps

Free PDF maps of Lake Milton with depth contours, ramps and docks, each credited to the agency that published it. Not for navigation.

  • Lake Milton Ohio Department of Natural Resources, lake last surveyed 1998, map revised 2010 · PDF, 0.5 MB

Timeline

39 dated newspaper stories, reports and records about Lake Milton, 1913 to 2025, each linked to its source.

Show all 39
  1. Epic 1913 Mahoning River flood cast wide net of destruction The Vindicator
  2. The Alliance review and leader. (Alliance, Ohio), 1918-05-09 The Alliance review and leader. (Alliance
  3. The Alliance review and leader. (Alliance, Ohio), 1918-06-03 The Alliance review and leader. (Alliance
  4. The Alliance review and leader. (Alliance, Ohio), 1918-06-07 The Alliance review and leader. (Alliance
  5. The Alliance review and leader. (Alliance, Ohio), 1918-06-11 The Alliance review and leader. (Alliance
  6. The Alliance review and leader. (Alliance, Ohio), 1918-06-20 The Alliance review and leader. (Alliance
  7. The Alliance review and leader. (Alliance, Ohio), 1918-07-05 The Alliance review and leader. (Alliance
  8. The Alliance review and leader. (Alliance, Ohio), 1918-07-06 The Alliance review and leader. (Alliance
  9. The Alliance review and leader. (Alliance, Ohio), 1918-07-09 The Alliance review and leader. (Alliance
  10. The Alliance review and leader. (Alliance, Ohio), 1918-07-10 The Alliance review and leader. (Alliance
  11. The Alliance review and leader. (Alliance, Ohio), 1918-07-11 The Alliance review and leader. (Alliance
  12. The Alliance review and leader. (Alliance, Ohio), 1918-07-15 The Alliance review and leader. (Alliance
  13. The Alliance review and leader. (Alliance, Ohio), 1918-07-17 The Alliance review and leader. (Alliance
  14. The Alliance review and leader. (Alliance, Ohio), 1918-07-22 The Alliance review and leader. (Alliance
  15. The Alliance review and leader. (Alliance, Ohio), 1918-07-31 The Alliance review and leader. (Alliance
  16. The Alliance review and leader. (Alliance, Ohio), 1918-08-05 The Alliance review and leader. (Alliance
  17. The Alliance review and leader. (Alliance, Ohio), 1918-08-07 The Alliance review and leader. (Alliance
  18. The Alliance review and leader. (Alliance, Ohio), 1918-08-09 The Alliance review and leader. (Alliance
  19. The Alliance review and leader. (Alliance, Ohio), 1918-08-12 The Alliance review and leader. (Alliance
  20. The Alliance review and leader. (Alliance, Ohio), 1918-08-14 The Alliance review and leader. (Alliance
  21. The Milan Ledger, 1921-06-02 The Milan Ledger
  22. The Milan Ledger., 1931-07-10 The Milan Ledger.
  23. CRAIG BEACH Fast facts The Vindicator
  24. LAKE MILTON STATE PARK NatureWorks grant from ODNR to fund amphitheater project The Vindicator
  25. Lake Milton Amphitheater opens, ready for shows The Vindicator
  26. Wakeboarding competition Saturday at Lake Milton State Park The Vindicator
  27. Farmers market to open in Lake Milton next week The Vindicator
  28. Check out this $2M view: Lake Milton Boat Club not buoyed by soaring land value The Vindicator
  29. Dam repairs at parks The Vindicator
  30. Milton Dam centennial to be observed The Vindicator
  31. Nearly 50 watercraft join parade to mark Lake Milton's centennial today The Vindicator
  32. Celebrating Lake Milton's centennial The Vindicator
  33. Authorities find body of Lake Milton boater The Vindicator
  34. Jack Wolllitz: Milton good place to 'bass' the time for Valley anglers The Vindicator
  35. 'McMansions' erected near Lake Milton Tribune Chronicle
  36. Little to luxurious: Home building booms in Milton The Vindicator
  37. Lake Milton Brewery thriving by diversifying The Vindicator
  38. Officials: Nothing fishy about dead shad at Lake Milton The Vindicator
  39. Second chance gave Lake Milton new life The Vindicator

Towns and ZIP codes around Lake Milton

Water, health, jobs and history for the places on the shores and just downstream.

Towns

ZIP codes

Questions

When was Lake Milton built?

The City of Youngstown began buying land in 1910 and had nearly all of it by the end of 1913. Newspapers of the day show the dam still under construction in 1914 and 1915, with the city promising completion by the end of 1916; the National Inventory of Dams lists 1916, and local tradition, including the 2017 centennial, counts from 1917.

What town is under Lake Milton?

Fredericksburg, or Frederick, a stagecoach-stop village laid out by Frederick Byers, who came to Milton Township about 1824, lies beneath the lake. It once had taverns, stores, a distillery and a tannery. The city bought out the reservoir basin between 1910 and 1915 and the water rose over it in 1916-17. A second riverside crossroads, Milton P.O., with a woolen mill and sawmill, also sat on the drowned corridor.

Why did Lake Milton drain completely in the 1980s?

The dam's right wingwall was found dangerously weak, threatening to flood Newton Falls five miles downstream if it failed. The city could not afford the repairs, so the state funded a rebuild, the lake was drained in 1986, and the gates closed again on March 31, 1988.

Who owns Lake Milton now?

The City of Youngstown owned it from construction through the 1986-88 rebuild. After the rebuild, the city asked the state to take it over; ODNR approved in fall 1988, and it was dedicated as Ohio's 72nd state park in 1988.

How big is Lake Milton?

The reservoir covers roughly 1,700 to 1,780 acres depending on the source, with a drainage area of about 273 to 276 square miles on the Mahoning River. ODNR draws it down about 8 feet each winter.

Did Dean Martin really perform at Lake Milton?

Yes. In 1934, 17-year-old Dino Crocetti made his stage debut at the Craig Beach dance hall on the lake, singing "Oh Marie" with the George Williams Orchestra, years before he became famous as Dean Martin.

More Ohio lakes

See them all

Cite this page

Cite this page as:

Cracked Buckeye, "Lake Milton", https://crackedbuckeye.com/lakes/milton/, built 2026-11-14, accessed [date].

How to cite · Report a correction · Built 2026-11-14