Deep dives · Hardin County, Lorain County, Clermont County, Athens County, Ashland County, Meigs County, Lawrence County, Pike County, Clark County, Ross County, Brown County

Ohio's Archaic period

Ohio's Archaic period ran 7,000 years. People here built dugout canoes, grew squash, buried dogs beside their dead and traded Lake Superior copper.

  • Published , updated

At a glance

A changing world after the ice

As the Pleistocene ended, Ohio's climate warmed toward its modern four-season pattern, and the Archaic period began as thick forests grew across Ohio (Ohio History Central). Ohio History Central splits the early Archaic into two working periods: Early Archaic, roughly 10,000 to 8,000 years before present, and Middle Archaic, 8,000 to 5,000 years before present (Ohio History Central). Its Late Archaic runs from 5,000 to 3,000 years before present, or 3,000 to 1,000 BCE (Ohio History Central). Archaeologist Matthew Purtill's statewide inventory of dates uses a slightly longer span, 10,950 to 2650 uncalibrated radiocarbon years before present, or 9000 to 700 BC in uncalibrated radiocarbon years (Ohio Archaeological Council). A mid-Holocene warm, dry spell known as the Hypsithermal, roughly 8,000 to 4,000 years ago, did not turn western Ohio into prairie: pollen from an 8.4-meter core at Crystal Lake in Clark County never shows grass, sedge and ragweed above 10 percent, and Kristin Kopera's 2019 Wright State University thesis found the vegetation there "insensitive" to the warming (Wright State University).

Early Archaic people lived in small, highly mobile bands that moved with the seasons, hunting deer, turkey, rabbit, passenger pigeons and waterfowl, fishing, and gathering berries, hickory nuts and acorns (Ohio History Central). Early in the period people were always on the move, sheltering in tents of wooden poles covered with bark or hides, and their leaders were men and women who had earned respect for their hunting, healing or other skills rather than chiefs (Ohio History Central). Ohio History Central's reconstruction of an Archaic base camp on the Maumee River, with families carving dugout canoes with stone axes, fishing and grinding nuts for winter storage, is based on research at the Dupont, Raisch-Smith and Weilnau sites (Ohio History Central). Their favorite stone stayed the same as their Paleoindian ancestors': Upper Mercer flint from Coshocton County and Flint Ridge flint from Licking County (Ohio History Central).

The Middle Archaic puzzle

During the Middle Archaic, groups grew larger and the toolkit diversified beyond spear points, knives and scrapers to include a new family of ground-stone tools: grooved axes, atlatl weights, grinding stones, pitted nutting stones, plummets and net sinkers (Ohio History Central). Ground-stone axes, made from hard stone such as granite, let people fell trees and shape the wood into dugout canoes (Ohio History Central). Yet the period is close to invisible in Ohio's dating record (Ohio Archaeological Council). As of July 2005, Purtill's inventory held 213 Archaic-age dates from 107 Ohio sites, but only five were Early Archaic and five Middle Archaic, against 203 Late Archaic (Ohio Archaeological Council). The span from about 7,900 to 6,300 radiocarbon years ago, usually defined as the Middle Archaic, "is devoid of dates," and Purtill has interpreted that 1,600-year gap as a substantial population reduction, out-migration or both (Ohio Archaeological Council). He acknowledged that "some may question my interpretation," but argued that most would agree the gap "is unexpected and needs better explanation" (Ohio Archaeological Council). The dates also cluster unevenly, with a disproportionate share from southern Ohio; one site alone, Maderia Brown in Pike County, yielded 20 dates spanning about 4233 to 3004 radiocarbon years before present (Ohio Archaeological Council).

One famous "Archaic" canoe turned out not to be Archaic at all (Journal of Ohio Archaeology). Harold Slessman, dredging peat from Mud Lake, part of Savannah Lakes in Ashland County, brought up the Ringler dugout on November 30, 1976, and a cold snap froze it on shore until the Cleveland Museum of Natural History moved it within a week (Journal of Ohio Archaeology). Shaped from a single white oak log 690 centimeters long, about 22.6 feet, it went through a preservation process of seven and a half years (Journal of Ohio Archaeology). It had been published in 1982 as an Archaic canoe, but in 2012 the museum's own team reported that three radiocarbon dates differ from that 1982 date and "place the making and use of the Dugout in the mid-seventeenth century" (Journal of Ohio Archaeology).

The atlatl and its puzzling stone accessories

Archaic hunters across this whole span relied on the atlatl, a wooden spear-thrower with a handle at one end and a hook at the other that let a dart be thrown much farther and harder than by an unaided arm (Ohio History Central). Darts thrown this way could penetrate Spanish chain mail, and the atlatl likely came to America with the first Paleoindians and remained the main hunting weapon until the bow and arrow replaced it in the Late Woodland period (Ohio History Central). Archaic people also carved and polished slate into a variety of shapes, many of them used as weights or decorations for their spear-throwers (Ohio History Central). Those bannerstones range from simple hollow tubes to elaborate winged forms, and some are so large and ornate that Ohio History Central compares them to the giant keys to the city that officials present to dignitaries (Ohio History Central). The earliest were made by Shell Mound Archaic people around 6000 BC, people in the Savannah River valley had begun making them by about 3800 BC, and after about 1500 BC they seem to disappear from the archaeological record, according to Archaeology magazine.

What bannerstones actually did remains genuinely unresolved (Archaeology magazine). Atlatl champion Larry Kinsella won the 1983 world title without one, then lost it the next year using a bannerstone he had made himself, which "helped with neither distance nor accuracy" (Archaeology magazine). When Herman Pontzer wired Kinsella to an electromyography machine and had him hold an atlatl ready to launch for two minutes, he found "much less muscle strain" with a bannerstone attached (Archaeology magazine). Many surviving bannerstones are also simply too heavy for practical use: one atlatl researcher, Robert Berg, reports handling examples weighing more than a pound, "very significant" compared with objects independently identified as genuine working atlatl weights, according to Berg's own analysis. In the Savannah River valley, archaeologist Kenneth Sassaman has found that the finest early bannerstones occur "exclusively in graves," and he suggests they may have been needed "for passage to the other world" (Archaeology magazine). At the Burrell Orchard site in Lorain County, half of a diamond-shaped slate bannerstone lay in a Late Archaic clay floor, and excavator Brian Redmond thinks it was ritually broken and buried there (Ideastream Public Media).

Birdstones are a related and equally debated art form: small carvings of what looks like a bird with a tapered bill and flared tail, some with bulging "popeyes," some showing only head and neck on an oval base (Ohio History Connection). The Ohio History Connection calls them "perhaps the most puzzling of all prehistoric American Indian objects," usually linked with the Glacial Kame people but also found at Late Archaic sites in New York and Pennsylvania (Ohio History Connection). One came out of the Ridgeway kame in 1856, described by the railroad supervisor as having a bird-like head and a hole drilled diagonally through its base (Cunningham, 1948).

A swept-clean house on Lake Erie

A key Archaic site on Ohio's Lake Erie shore is Burrell Orchard (33LN15), in Sheffield Village, Lorain County, on Lorain County Metroparks land in what was once the orchard of the 1820 Burrell homestead (Ideastream Public Media). Smaller digs explored the site as far back as 1971 (University Circle). In 2015 a Cleveland Museum of Natural History team under Brian Redmond reported a floor about 3 inches thick, built of layers of yellow clay carried from nearby, with a basin, cooking pits and storage holes for hickory nuts built into it (University Circle). Post molds at its edges would have anchored hickory saplings tied together wigwam-style and covered with cattail mats (University Circle). The floors were laid one on top of another, as if the builders were reflooring their house (Ideastream Public Media). "There's nothing like this anywhere in Ohio," Redmond said (Archaeology magazine).

Redmond's team concluded that people came back to Burrell Orchard off and on for at least 500 years, mainly in fall and winter, eating hickory nuts, deer and fish from Lake Erie and the Black River, and that they swept their floor, since little was found inside the house (Ideastream Public Media). In 2017 Redmond argued in American Antiquity that the clay floors were shrines, possibly tied to hunting ritual, built inside an ordinary Late Archaic base camp. Thick midden layers of burned rock, nutshell and deer bone show everyday seasonal work going on alongside (American Antiquity).

Along the Ohio River: Maple Creek and its neighbors

In southwestern Ohio, archaeologist Kent Vickery defined the Maple Creek phase in 1976 and 1980 from radiocarbon dates at the Maple Creek site (33Ct52) and from Merom-Trimble points, placing it between about 1700 and 1000 BC (Ohio Archaeological Council). Its people also used McWhinney points and a chipped-flint micro-tool industry of drills, gravers and tiny perforators, while atlatl parts and bell pestles are absent or very rare (Ohio Archaeological Council). Vickery's two key base camps, Maple Creek and Logan (33Ct30), lie along the Ohio River in Clermont County, and he proposed that the largest "regional" base camps drew many bands together for six months or longer (Ohio Archaeological Council). Later finds pushed the phase west into Boone and Carroll counties, Kentucky, and east to the Yellowbush Creek Camp site (33Ms29) on an Ohio River terrace near Racine in Meigs County, dated 1916 to 1267 BC (Ohio Archaeological Council). Where the phase ends is still argued: at Davisson Farm (33Le619) in Lawrence County, only four Merom-Trimble points turned up against 21 Brewerton points, one key reason Purtill does not place that site in the Maple Creek phase (Ohio Archaeological Council).

The uplands are turning out to matter too (Ohio Archaeological Council, 2025). At site 33Ha899, on a ridge 70 meters above the Great Miami River near Taylors Creek in southwest Ohio, a magnetic survey found more than 320 buried anomalies in 1.35 acres, and excavated refuse pits held about 8,600 artifacts, turtle-shell bowls, polished bone objects and a dog burial (Ohio Archaeological Council, 2025). Radiocarbon dates on nut hulls, charcoal and dog remains fall between 4970 and 4449 calibrated years ago, and the site suggests upland camps were used more intensely in the Late Archaic than archaeologists had assumed (Ohio Archaeological Council, 2025). Two Clermont County Archaic sites, the Devanney Site near Goshen and the Bullskin Creek Site near Felicity, were added to the National Register of Historic Places on March 30, 1978 (National Park Service, Devanney; National Park Service, Bullskin Creek).

Ohio's first farmers

Eastern North America was one of the few places in the world where people began domesticating plants without significant outside influence (Ohio History Central). Before about 4,000 years ago there is only isolated evidence for single native domesticates in the region, but by 3,800 years ago at least five domesticated seed plants were being grown together at the Riverton site in Illinois, according to Bruce Smith and Richard Yarnell in PNAS. They read that first crop complex as an expansion of a stable hunting and gathering economy in rich river valleys, not an abrupt break or a response to crowding (PNAS). Ohio History Central credits Late Archaic groups here as the first to grow crops — "mainly squash, sunflowers, and marsh elder" — in gardens that were tended less intensively than the gardens of the following Early Woodland period (Ohio History Central).

The strongest specific Ohio evidence for this shift comes from the County Home site (33At40) in Athens County, where Paul Patton and Sabrina Curran measured chenopod seed-coat thickness and marsh-elder seed size and identified domesticated types dating to about 3,600 to 3,000 years ago (Midcontinental Journal of Archaeology). Recovered from hearths and earth ovens alongside other cultivated plants, they are some of the earliest evidence of plant domestication outside the oak-hickory and oak-savannah forests of eastern North America, and show that domesticated crops reached the Appalachian mixed-forest zone of the middle Ohio Valley earlier than had previously been documented (Midcontinental Journal of Archaeology). Corn, by contrast, did not become a major crop in the Ohio area until about AD 750 (Ohio History Connection).

Pottery arrived at the same boundary (Ohio History Central), and the Ohio History Connection's own texts frame it two ways. Its 2023 Ohio History Central entry calls Late Archaic peoples the first documented to make pottery in Ohio, large thick-walled vessels for storing water and nut or seed oil, heavy enough to suggest people were settling down for at least part of the year (Ohio History Central). Its older First Ohioans exhibit text instead gives the earliest Ohio date to Early Woodland potters in Jackson County, by about 1020 BC, and dates the pottery fragments from the Leimbach site in Erie County to about 520 BC (Ohio History Connection).

Copper roads and a hilltop cemetery

Archaic people in the Lake Superior region produced heavy copper tools in what archaeologists call the Old Copper Complex, and wood and cordage embedded in 15 of its copper artifacts date between 8500 and 3580 calibrated years before present, making it "among the oldest known metalworking societies in the world," according to a 2021 study of 53 radiocarbon dates in Radiocarbon. Much of the copper used in prehistoric eastern North America came from Isle Royale and Michigan's Keweenaw Peninsula, while smaller amounts of "float copper" were found locally in glacial sand and gravel (Ohio History Connection). Ohio History Central credits Late Archaic groups such as the Glacial Kame people with trading with distant groups for copper and sea shells, ornaments that may have belonged to leaders, respected hunters or healers and were buried with them as symbols of high status (Ohio History Central). The Glacial Kame and other Late Archaic cultures of the Ohio Valley obtained objects of marine shell native to the west coast of Florida, though no workshop where such pieces were made has been found (Ohio History Connection). Their signature "sandal-sole" gorget, shaped like the sole of a shoe, was nearly always drilled with three holes in the same positions, for reasons unknown, and one Late Archaic gorget was engraved with a bear (Ohio History Connection).

In northwestern Ohio, the Glacial Kame people buried certain people in kames, the large natural mounds of gravel left by glaciers, and archaeologists suspect those buried there were leaders or important figures (Ohio History Central). The type site, the Ridgeway Site, lies near the Bellefontaine and Indiana Railway between Mount Victory and Ridgeway in Hardin County, where in the fall of 1856 John S. Matson began removing a gravel bank to ballast the railroad and learned that it was an ancient burial ground (Cunningham, 1948). His report, reprinted in Wilbur Cunningham's 1948 University of Michigan study, describes a double mound covering an acre and a half under a bearing apple orchard (Cunningham). "The whole number of skeletons exhumed by me was three hundred and eight," Matson wrote, not counting those dug out earlier by sand diggers (Cunningham); the Ohio History Connection gives the total removed in 1856 as 380 (Ohio History Connection). Matson recorded at least 50 children under eight, seven or eight people with bone tracheas that he took as a sign of extreme age, a pit holding 27 skulls set in rows on a mass of loose bones, and one deep-buried man wrapped in what he estimated as nearly thirty yards of shell beads (Cunningham). He thought the copper looked like Lake Superior copper, and he found "no evidence of pottery" (Cunningham).

Nearby, on Arthur Zimmerman's farm about three miles north of Belle Center in Hardin County, gravel hauling in the summer of 1931 uncovered 148 human skeletons in an area about 100 by 200 feet, along with more than fourteen sandal-sole gorgets and two small pots (Cunningham, 1948). A Hardin County kame of the same name, the Zimmerman Kame near Roundhead, was listed on the National Register of Historic Places on July 30, 1974 (National Park Service). Whether "Glacial Kame" names a real culture is an old question: in his 1948 appendix, James B. Griffin wrote that the finds describe "a burial complex," not a culture, because more than half of the 61 traits listed occur at only one site and only the sandal-sole gorget appears at all eleven (Cunningham).

Red Ocher caches and the Maumee cemeteries

Late Archaic people also left caches of their finest flint work (Ohio History Connection). The Red Ocher people made "turkey-tail" points, named for a base shaped like a plucked turkey's tail, and sometimes piled them beside cremated bodies or broke large numbers on purpose and buried the pieces together (Ohio History Connection). Construction workers found a cache of 200 of these points in Ross County, and a farmer plowing his field in Brown County found nearly 350 more (Ohio History Connection). Nearly all are made of high-quality Indiana flint, so they clearly passed from group to group, and some archaeologists think that breaking and burying them may have raised their value by taking them out of circulation (Ohio History Connection).

Some Late Archaic cemeteries were very large (Ohio History Connection). University of Toledo archaeologists found 18 burial pits at the Williams site, in an eroded area along the Maumee River, holding at least 500 people, many of them cremated, with dates running from 850 to 380 BC, which overlaps the Early Woodland period as Ohio History Central dates it (below) (Ohio History Connection). Cemeteries like these suggest that people chose particular places to bury their kin and carried the dead there even from far away, over long periods (Ohio History Connection).

Dogs at the fire

Dogs were already old companions to people in this era (American Antiquity). At the Koster site in Greene County, Illinois, two dogs, and a third from the Stilwell II site in Pike County, Illinois, are directly radiocarbon-dated to between 10,190 and 9,630 calibrated years before present, the earliest confirmed domestic dogs in the Americas and the oldest individual dog burials known anywhere in the world, according to a study by Angela Perri and colleagues in American Antiquity. Those Early Archaic dogs were medium-sized, lived active lives and ate a diet heavy in land resources and river fish (American Antiquity). In Ohio, Matson found "not less than ten or twelve dogs" buried at Ridgeway, "the human and canine side by side" (Cunningham, 1948), and site 33Ha899 in southwest Ohio held a dog burial among its Late Archaic refuse pits (Ohio Archaeological Council, 2025).

From Archaic to Woodland

By the close of the Archaic, burial was saying more about the living (Ohio History Central). Objects taken from Late Archaic burials vary in quality and quantity, many were made of materials from far away such as Indiana flint, Lake Superior copper and Gulf and Atlantic shells, and men were often buried with spear points and hunting tools while women were often buried with bone awls, needles and scrapers (Ohio History Central). Some archaeologists speculate from such funerary objects that Late Archaic groups held shamanistic beliefs, possibly shared with groups in the Great Lakes region (Ohio History Central). Today archaeologists generally consult Ohio tribes before investigating an ancient burial site, and since 1990 the Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act has required museums to consult with federally recognized nations about human remains and funerary objects (Ohio History Central). Pottery, small gardens, long-distance trade and status-marked burial carried straight into the Early Woodland period, which Ohio History Central dates to 2,800 to 2,000 years before present (Ohio History Central), and into the Adena culture, which began raising Ohio's first burial mounds around 800 BC (Ohio History Central).

Sources

Towns and ZIP codes

Water, health, jobs and history for the places on the shores and just downstream.

Towns

Questions

How long did Ohio's Archaic period last?

About 7,000 years. Ohio History Central's working periods run from about 10,000 years ago, when the Early Archaic began, to about 3,000 years ago, when the Late Archaic ended, roughly 8000 to 1000 BC; archaeologist Matthew Purtill's statewide date inventory uses 9000 to 700 BC in uncalibrated radiocarbon years. It is the longest single chapter in Ohio's human history, but it left no mounds or monuments, so it is also the least known.

What is a bannerstone, and what was it for?

A bannerstone is a carved and polished stone, usually banded slate, drilled through the center and attached somewhere along an atlatl (spear-thrower) shaft. What it actually did is disputed: atlatl champion Larry Kinsella threw no better with one, but tests with Herman Pontzer found that a bannerstone sharply cut the muscle strain of holding a loaded atlatl ready. Ohio History Central notes that some are too large and ornate for a working atlatl, which is why archaeologists think at least the finest pieces were symbols of status.

Did Archaic people in Ohio farm?

In a small way. By the last two millennia BC, Late Archaic people in Ohio were growing gardens of squash, sunflower and marsh elder, native plants domesticated independently in eastern North America long before corn became a major crop. Chenopod and marsh-elder seeds from the County Home site in Athens County show clear signs of domestication and date to about 3,600 to 3,000 years ago.

What was the Glacial Kame culture?

A Late Archaic burial tradition of northwestern and west-central Ohio and neighboring states, whose people buried some of their dead in kames, the gravel hills left behind by melting glaciers. Its best-known site, the Ridgeway Site between Ridgeway and Mount Victory in Hardin County, was found in 1856 when a railroad crew dug the hill for track ballast; the supervisor counted 308 skeletons, with shell beads, copper, sandal-sole shell gorgets and ten or twelve dogs buried beside people.

How old are the oldest known dog burials in the Midwest?

At the Koster site in Illinois, two individually buried dogs, and a third from the nearby Stilwell II site, are directly radiocarbon-dated to roughly 10,190-9,630 calibrated years ago, the earliest confirmed domestic dogs in the Americas and the oldest individual dog burials known anywhere in the world.

Why are there so few Middle Archaic dates in Ohio?

Nobody is sure. Matthew Purtill's 2005 inventory of 213 Archaic radiocarbon and other absolute dates from Ohio found only five Early Archaic and five Middle Archaic dates, and none at all between about 7,900 and 6,300 radiocarbon years ago. Purtill reads the gap as a real population drop or move out of the state; he acknowledges others may question that, but says the gap needs explaining.

What are turkey-tail points?

Large, finely made Late Archaic spear points with a base shaped like a plucked turkey's tail, made by the Red Ocher people, nearly all from high-quality Indiana flint. They were often buried in caches: construction workers found a cache of 200 in Ross County, and a farmer plowing in Brown County found nearly 350.

When did people in Ohio first make pottery?

Around the end of the Archaic, but the Ohio History Connection's own texts frame it two ways. Its 2023 Ohio History Central entry credits Late Archaic people with Ohio's first documented pottery, while its older First Ohioans exhibit text gives the earliest date to Early Woodland potters in Jackson County, by about 1020 BC.

Is the Ringler dugout canoe from the Archaic?

No. The 22-foot white oak dugout, dredged from Mud Lake in Ashland County on November 30, 1976, was published in 1982 as an Archaic canoe, but in 2012 the Cleveland Museum of Natural History team reported three radiocarbon dates placing its making and use in the mid-1600s AD.

More deep dives

See them all

Cite this page

Cite this page as:

Cracked Buckeye, "Ohio's Archaic period", https://crackedbuckeye.com/deep-dives/ohio-archaic-period/, built 2026-11-14, accessed [date].

How to cite · Report a correction · Built 2026-11-14