Ohio lakes · Logan County

Indian Lake

Built 1851-60 over a ceded Shawnee and Seneca reservation, Indian Lake had a famous dance hall and saw National Guard riot duty.

  • Built 1860
  • 5,104 acres
  • Great Miami River (headwaters)
  • Ohio Department of Natural Resources
  • Published , updated

Summer temperature by depth

Only 1 summer temperature profile with depth has been found for Indian Lake (1977-1977), too few to say what is typical.

Past measurements, not live readings: USGS Ohio Water Science Center, 2 profiles 1977. From the Water Quality Portal, the EPA National Lakes Assessment and the Army Corps' lake records.

At a glance

Before the lake

Indian Lake's land carries two stories of taking, decades apart. The Shawnee established a cluster of towns across what became Logan County, among them Lewis' Town, today's Lewistown, on what is now the lake's shore. Its leader was Quatawapea, "the man on the water who sinks and rises again," known to Americans as Colonel Lewis; McKenney and Hall's History of the Indian Tribes of North America says he was born on the Pickaway Plains, was a boy at the 1774 battle on the Kanawha (Point Pleasant), received a medal from Secretary of War Henry Dearborn, and in the War of 1812 joined the American army with a small band of warriors. The Eastern Shawnee Tribe of Oklahoma traces its own origin to this group: around 1813 its progenitor was "known as the Lewistown Band of Shawnee," led by "Qua-ta-wa-pea," known to Americans as Colonel Lewis.

The 1817 Treaty of Fort Meigs created three Shawnee reservations in Ohio, at Hog Creek, Wapakoneta and Lewistown; the Lewistown reserve was shared with an independent band of Seneca who had allied themselves with the Shawnee. It covered 48 square miles, and the 1818 Treaty of St. Mary's added 8,960 acres, bringing the combined reserve to roughly 39,700 acres. Lewis himself was eventually deposed by his band on a charge of misusing its federal money; McKenney and Hall say he moved with his family and a few followers west of the Mississippi, where he died in 1826, five years before the reservation he had led was ceded. On July 20, 1831, at Lewistown, U.S. Commissioner James B. Gardiner and Indian Agent John McElvain concluded the Treaty of Lewistown with the reserve's chiefs, Little Lewis, Civil John, Robbin, Run Fast, John Young, Yankee Bill and Cold Water among the signers, ceding the entire reservation in exchange for 60,000 replacement acres west of the Mississippi, a $6,000 advance for improvements left behind, a saw-mill and blacksmith shop, and a 5% annuity on the land-sale proceeds; it was proclaimed April 6, 1832. A 1903 county history records that the band was not removed until the following year, and the people who went west became part of what is today the Eastern Shawnee Tribe of Oklahoma.

Before the reservoir, glaciers had left a cluster of shallow, marshy kettle lakes covering about 640 acres, which ODNR names as Old Indian Lake, Otter Lake, Black Lake, Sheep Pen Lake, Brush Lake and Little Lake. The 1903 county history describes the original Indian Lake as three or four hundred acres, "one of the famous fishing resorts of the Indians," with the Miami River running through it; the reservoir "contains within its enclosure the original Indian lake."

About 1850, the same county history says, John M. Warwick of Amherst County, Virginia, resolved to free his slaves, "some three hundred in number", and with Dr. David Patterson bought a large tract in the northeast corner of Stokes Township, "on the waters of Indian lake"; the freed families arrived early in 1851 and built cabins. "Unfortunately about this time the Lewistown reservoir was built," the history continues, and backwater covered large parts of their land and left the lowlands "unhealthy and malarious"; the settlement "was in great measure broken up, and the colored people scattered far and near," though some stayed in the neighborhood.

Building the dam

In its report of January 1841 the Board of Public Works ordered a survey of the embankments "of the Lewistown or Logan county reservoir," meant to hold the floodwaters of the Miami's headwater branches for the dry months and expected to "cover an area of about 5000 acres." In March 1849 the General Assembly told the Board to examine the site in the northwest corner of Logan County and report "the cost and advantage" of a reservoir there. In 1850 the Ohio General Assembly authorized using the Lewistown lakes to supply the canal. Construction ran 1851 to 1860 at a cost of $340,000, with a bulkhead in Washington Township where the Great Miami begins, built by Irish laborers "with picks, shovels and carts." By October 1851 a Kalida paper was advertising that "hundreds of hands are wanted at the Lewistown Reservoir" at the highest wages. An Indian Lake Area Historical Society marker adds that workers were paid a dollar a day plus room, board "and a shot of whisky," moving dirt with horse-drawn wooden scoops. Laborers built roughly three miles of earthen dam in several sections, joining seven natural lakes and large ponds into one reservoir. Because the dam followed the irregular edges of existing high ground rather than a single straight embankment, the resulting lake kept an irregular shoreline and many islands that had simply been higher ground. The completed Lewistown Reservoir covered 6,334 acres with 29 miles of shoreline by 1893, and the state's own park marker calls the result the second-largest man-made lake of its time, a frequently repeated claim not traced to a period engineering report. The original spillway, an ogee-shaped concrete weir 700 feet long and 10 feet high, stood for more than 150 years before its 2017-2018 replacement; in 1875 the resident engineer described the waste-weir as "six hundred feet long".

Not everyone wanted it. In January 1853 Representative Casad moved to require the Board to "abate the nuisance formed by the construction of the Lewistown Reservoir," and lost; that March he joked on the House floor that it should remain as it was, as "a proper place for the gentleman from Crawford to wash his sheep in." Canal towns downstream wanted more water, not less, and on April 7, 1856, the legislature authorized the Board to enlarge the reservoir on condition that sales of surplus canal water pay for the work. The Board let the contract without public notice to M. C. Ryan, James G. Haley and T. L. P. Defrees, who promised an enlargement of not less than 5,000 acres in all by July 1, 1858, in return for the canal's water power from St. Marys to the Ohio River. They assigned the contract to the Miami Hydraulic and Manufacturing Company, whose engineer, William J. Jackson of Napoleon, testified that work began about October 1, 1856. In April 1858 the General Assembly passed an act "to cancel the contract for the enlargement of the Lewistown Reservoir" and had the auditor, attorney general and secretary of state settle the company's accounts. Their 1859 report found that former state treasurer William H. Gibson had lent the reservoir company $24,000 of public money that never returned to the treasury, a thread of the larger Breslin-Gibson treasury scandal.

An 1857 appropriation set aside $20,000 "to pay for lands in original Lewistown Reservoir, including expenses of appraisement and condemnation". The state treasury's November 1858 statement shows $9,900.50 deposited by the canal commissioner "on account of Lands taken for Lewistown Reservoir", and the Board's accounts for that fiscal year include $3,790 "paid for land in original Lewistown Reservoir". One April 1858 act, printed in Columbus's German paper, directed the Board to take the land of Walter Slicer within the original reservoir and pay him $1,600 from the money set aside for flooded land. In 1866 the Board paid $135 "for 9 acres of land in Lewistown Reservoir", about $15 an acre.

In 1868 the Board promised a special report on "claims for damages done in the construction of the Lewistown reservoir". A resolution of March 18, 1870, directed it to condemn as easements "the right to flood certain lands near the Lewistown Reservoir", with W. H. West of Bellefontaine handling the legal work. In its report for 1873 the Board admitted it was "not yet sufficiently in possession of facts" to report on the damages. In 1875 Resident Engineer John W. Erwin and Bellefontaine surveyor Henry C. Moore traced the top-water line and listed the private tracts below it: Dennis Cox, 13.35 acres; James Ewing, two tracts of 7.88 and 6.01 acres; Lafayette Stamate, 58.90; Jamison & Couch, 38.97; Richard, Reuben and Robert Warwick, 8.70, 13.73 and 0.88; John Snodgrass, 0.10; Wilson Rose, 68.08; and Hugh Beatty, 75.38. Moore "could not find any title in the State on record" for several of them, and Erwin rejected John Archer's claim for $2,400 as "a matter of impossibility" on the levels he measured. The sources do not say whether the three Warwicks on Erwin's list were connected to the Warwick freedmen's settlement.

It is not known whether any cemetery was displaced by the flooding; Lewistown itself, the village the reservoir is named for, was platted around the time the Shawnee left and was still a village with its own school and taverns in the 1903 county history. In the same 1875 report the state sold surplus land it had found around the reservoir: 675.05 of 1,130 surveyed acres went at auction on August 31, 1875 to 14 buyers, including Thomas Axtell, who bought tracts that included Red-oak, Snow, Pony, Scott, Lake Ridge, Small and Mud Branch islands. Red Oak, Snow and Pony islands still carry those names on ODNR's fishing map. Later state land dealings include an 1891 lease: John Russell, who had settled a point of land around 1876, formalized it by leasing seven acres from the state for $48 a year; three years of a "constant stream of visitors" was more than the family bargained for, and in 1894 Russell sold the land, which kept his name, Russells Point, to two other men and moved his family away.

Stories

The resort era

The 1903 county history names Lake Ridge Island's hotel, Reed's Cottage, Lakeview, Russell's Point and Prater's as resorts, notes that the Toledo & Ohio Central Railroad "carries thousands of visitors to these resorts every year," and reports that the railroad "has lately become proprietors of Russell's Point," with "extensive improvements" planned. By 1930, a society marker says, 13 pleasure boats and 17 speed boats worked out of Russells Point Harbor. Dancing came early: the Dreamland and Lakeview dancing pavilions both opened on May 30, 1912. By the late 1920s the Big Four railroad ran Sunday excursions from Indianapolis advertising "Bathing, Dancing, Boating, Fishing, Airplane Trips, Speed Boats" and "One of the Largest Dance Pavilions in Ohio." Vaudeville and nightclub star Roscoe Ails kept a summer home at Russells Point, where, his wife alleged in a 1936 New York separation suit, he had pulled her hair during an argument the summer before; the court denied her alimony.

Sandy Beach: "Ohio's Million Dollar Playground"

Samuel L. "Pappy" Wilgus and his son French opened Sandy Beach Amusement Park on Decoration Day, May 30, 1924. Its centerpiece, the Minnewawa Dance Hall, cost about $50,000 to build and was billed at its opening as "the largest [dance hall] in the state and the fifth largest in the United States," holding 4,000 people under two alternating bandstands, with a strict dress code and no alcohol on the floor. The park's other draws included a National Amusement Device wooden roller coaster, a walk-through funhouse called the Mysterious Knockout, the Old Mill boat ride shown on 1920s postcards, and later a Philadelphia Toboggan Company carousel that, after it left the park, was relocated to Six Flags Over Mid-America, meaning a piece of Logan County is still spinning in Missouri. On the night of Saturday, September 21, 1935, fire swept the amusement park, destroying the large dance hall and part of the roller coaster with damage put at more than $100,000; firemen from surrounding towns saved the nearby cottages. Dancing went on in new halls: Danceland opened in 1940 and later became the Stardust Ballroom, then the San Juan Ballroom from 1957 to 1964. In 1957 George B. Quatman bought the west side of the park and in 1962 the east, renamed it San Juan Amusement Park and banned alcohol; in 1964 he raised the Our Lady of Fatima statue, then billed as the world's largest of the Virgin. In 1967 the park was sold to Venice Amusements and renamed Indian Lake Playland, and the Danceland ballroom became the Black Pearl, with Frankie Valli and the Four Seasons and Herman's Hermits on its stage.

The 1931 dance marathon

In September 1930, Betty Putterbaugh and Elwell McDowell won $1,000 after 1,688 hours at the Marathon Theatre. The following year, Charles Murray and Mary Rock Fite set the record most often cited today: 1,922 hours, roughly 80 days, for a $600 prize.

The islands: hilltops that never got wet

Every island in today's Indian Lake was, before 1851, simply high ground the dam's builders let the water rise around rather than level. A historical society marker lists the areas that grew on them, from Orchard and Wolf islands to the bridged chain called Indian Isles, among them Shawnee, Seminole, Tecumseh and Minnewauken, many "named in honor of Indian Tribes."

The July 4th riots

On July 4, 1961, revelers who wanted to keep partying when the bars along the harbor tried to close started the first of several annual riots; one heritage account puts that first crowd at nearly 500 youths. An Associated Press roundup that September recalled that Russells Point "was the scene of a youth demonstration July 4 which was broken up by fire hoses," and reported that about 250 youths who gathered there on Labor Day 1961 were quickly dispersed by officers alerted to trouble. By the same weekend in 1965, coinciding with a much more heavily reported riot at Geneva-on-the-Lake, National Guard troops dealt with roughly 1,500 rioting youths at Russells Point, with about 100 arrests. For almost a decade, the society's marker says, the park and community struggled with a reputation "caused by outside troublemakers", and attendance and investment fell. The declining Indian Lake Playland did not open for the 1976 season and was razed in August 1981. Only its steel arch footbridge survives; restored by the Reed family and the Indian Lake Area Historical Society, it was rededicated August 23, 2014, drawing what local coverage called one of the largest crowds since the amusement park days.

The lake since

The reservoir had been the canal's lifeline in dry years: in 1870 the Board wrote that without it "there would have been an entire suspension of navigation on a large portion of the canal for half the season," and after the dry autumn of 1873 the Lewistown and Loramie reservoirs were emptied about November 15 after nearly five months of draft. On April 9, 1898, the Ohio General Assembly dedicated the lake as a recreation area by the name of Indian Lake, settling a date that secondary sources had given as either 1896 or 1898. As canals gave way to railroads, a state marker says, the Miami and Erie operated until 1906, when it was abandoned, though the 1903 county history still called the lake the Lewistown Reservoir. By 1940 the state's Division of Conservation was advertising "State-owned Indian Lake" as Indian Lake State Park, with camping on Fox Island and Black Hawk Island and about nine square miles of water. In 1949 the Department of Conservation was abolished and the lake passed to the new Ohio Department of Natural Resources' Division of Parks and Recreation. Today the park offers five launch ramps, about 500 seasonal docks, unlimited-horsepower boating and two beaches with 1,400 feet of shore.

In 2017-2018, ODNR replaced the deteriorating 1850s ogee spillway, its 150-plus-year-old concrete causing seepage and instability along the earthen embankment, with a two-stage, 35-cycle labyrinth weir just 180 feet long, engineered to fit the historic spillway's capacity into a much shorter footprint. The state's marker notes that the old spillway had been resurfaced in 1959 and repaired in 1972 before structural problems grew. At the time it was the nation's second-largest spillway of its design; the project cost about $7.4-7.6 million and was completed in 2018, though the dam's condition assessment was still rated "Poor" in a 2019 inspection, suggesting the embankment itself, not the new spillway, remains the outstanding concern.

On the evening of March 14, 2024, an EF3 tornado with winds estimated at 155 mph tracked 32 miles from north of Botkins in Auglaize County through Lakeview, Russells Point and Orchard Island, between 7:29 and 8:16 p.m., killing three people and injuring 27; the National Weather Service survey found numerous manufactured homes completely destroyed in a mobile home park. One-year recovery coverage in March 2025 described a slow rebuilding, with some businesses back and others still working through insurance and zoning. ODNR's lake consultant later suggested the storm may also have stirred up the water: the 2024 Secchi clarity readings were lower than in any earlier year, even 1973, likely from algae and elevated suspended solids that "may have resulted from the extreme tornadic event."

The water

Indian Lake is not a drinking-water source; it is managed strictly as a recreation and fishery reservoir, and its NID record lists recreation as its only purpose. Its spillway on the south shore drains into the Great Miami River, making the lake the river's headwater impoundment, and Ohio EPA, as cited in the same report, estimates the mean hydraulic retention time at about 275 days.

The lake has lost roughly 45% of its storage volume to siltation since 1973, when the National Eutrophication Survey measured about 46,280 acre-feet of storage at a 7.5-foot mean depth; a 2022 bathymetric resurvey found only about 20,686 acre-feet at a 4.5-foot mean depth. That decline drives an active, ongoing state dredging program: one high-priority and five moderate-priority areas were identified in 2024, at a cost of $30-50 per cubic yard removed, and the consultant warned that dredging the main basin "will not result in improved water quality," recommending strategic dredging only where navigation is impaired. In February 2024 the state capital budget set aside $5 million for dredging at Indian Lake. The 1973 survey found about 94% of the lake's phosphorus inputs came from nonpoint sources, not permitted point sources, and RLS now classes the lake as hyper-eutrophic, with the blue-green alga Microcystis common. Ohio EPA rates it "Not Supporting" for recreation, with pathogens and habitat alteration as listed causes, and in June 2024 the county health district investigated a possible harmful algal bloom along Oldfield Beach. Invasive Eurasian watermilfoil covered about 1,900 acres in 2022 before treatment brought it down to 22 acres by 2024; curly-leaf pondweed still covered roughly 2,275 acres in April 2024, and ODNR harvested it mechanically rather than poison it and risk an oxygen crash.

ODNR stocks the lake with nearly 5 million saugeye fry a year, and it is rated one of the best bluegill fisheries in central Ohio. The park lists largemouth bass, saugeye, white bass, crappie, bluegill, walleye, yellow perch and catfish as plentiful. In 1965 and 1967 the Division of Wildlife built two 85-foot stone fishing piers near Russells Point on the grounds of the former Indian Lake State Fish Hatchery. The lake sits on a major migration route, and ODNR notes that bald eagles have nested near it in recent years.

Sources

Fishing and depth maps

Free PDF maps of Indian Lake with depth contours, ramps and docks, each credited to the agency that published it. Not for navigation.

  • Indian Lake Ohio Department of Natural Resources, lake last surveyed 1999, map revised 2018 · PDF, 1.3 MB

Timeline

40 dated newspaper stories, reports and records about Indian Lake, 1817 to 2026, each linked to its source.

Show all 40
  1. Treaty of the Miami Rapids (Treaty of Fort Meigs) creates the Lewistown Reservation Treaty text
  2. Treaty of St. Mary's adds 8,960 acres to the Lewistown Reservation Treaty text
  3. Ohio General Assembly resolves to dam the Lewistown lakes for the Sidney Feeder canal Ohio General Assembly
  4. John Russell leases seven acres from the state Bureau of Public Works Logan County History
  5. State purchases and renames the reservoir 'Indian Lake' cprealestate.com
  6. First bridge to Orchard Island completed Wikipedia, Orchard Island
  7. Pappy and French Wilgus begin running the Sandy Beach bathing resort Peak of Ohio, dance halls
  8. Post office opens at Russells Point Village of Russells Point
  9. Great Flood of 1913 ends commercial use of the Ohio-Miami canal system Statewide flood retrospectives
  10. Ohio Conservancy Law creates the state's conservancy-district system Muskingum Watershed Conservancy District blog
  11. Acme Hotel built at Russells Point Vintage Postcards of Indian Lake
  12. Mysterious Knockout funhouse installed by Miller & Baker Company Coasterpedia
  13. First major Russells Point July 4th riot: nearly 500 youths involved GOTL Summer Fun Heritage Trail
  14. Former Sandy Beach Amusement Park site razed Peak of Ohio, Sandy Beach Bridge
  15. Annual Indian Lake Area Chamber of Commerce Legislative Luncheon covers capital projects Peak of Ohio
  16. Construction begins on Indian Lake's new labyrinth-weir spillway Association of State Dam Safety Officials
  17. David Hamilton, 59, of Rawson, dies after boat capsizes at Indian Lake WHIO TV 7
  18. Steven Opritza, 73, drowns after leaving his watercraft WHIO TV 7
  19. ODNR: 1 in critical condition after boating accident at Indian Lake Monday WHIO TV 7
  20. Body Found in Indian Lake on July 4th Identified Peak of Ohio
  21. Snowmobiler Rescued From Icy Indian Lake Peak of Ohio
  22. Cross Delivers Over $5 Million to Indian Lake Projects Peak of Ohio
  23. EF-3 tornado strikes Fryburg, Lakeview, Russells Point and Orchard Island Wikipedia / multiple regional outlets
  24. NWS teams survey destruction as Logan County community picks up the pieces cwcolumbus.com
  25. Central Ohio's deadly tornadoes: One week later Spectrum News 1
  26. Dewine Announces Reopening of Indian Lake; Community to Embrace Visitors Peak of Ohio
  27. Possible Algal Bloom at Indian Lake Peak of Ohio
  28. Indian Lake: A Premier Destination Inland Fishery Peak of Ohio
  29. Security camera footage sheds light on drowning at Indian Lake Bellefontaine Examiner
  30. UPDATE: Man Drowns in Indian Lake Peak of Ohio
  31. Indian Lake community continues rebuilding 1 year after devastating tornado Spectrum News 1
  32. Governor’s Inland Fish Ohio Day at Indian Lake Peak of Ohio
  33. ODNR and Indian Lake Watershed Project discuss spring plans for Indian Lake Peak of Ohio
  34. Authorities respond to late-night boating accident at Indian Lake Peak of Ohio
  35. Authorities respond to late-night boating accident at Indian Lake Peak of Ohio
  36. Driver in Saturday’s boat accident at Indian Lake identified and charged Peak of Ohio
  37. Dayton man cited for boating under the influence on Indian Lake Peak of Ohio
  38. Ice fishers take to Indian Lake on Sunday Peak of Ohio
  39. Safety, service, stewardship: Natural Resources Officers at Indian Lake Peak of Ohio
  40. Reminisce: Reservoir becomes Indian Lake Park LimaOhio.com

Towns and ZIP codes around Indian Lake

Water, health, jobs and history for the places on the shores and just downstream.

Towns

ZIP codes

Questions

When was Indian Lake built?

The Ohio General Assembly authorized it in 1850; construction ran 1851 to 1860, joining seven natural glacial lakes and ponds behind about three miles of earthen dam at a cost of $340,000, to feed the Miami and Erie Canal's Sidney Feeder. A second phase, the 1856-1858 enlargement, was built by a private contractor and ended in a legislative scandal.

What's under Indian Lake?

Before the dam, the site held about 640 acres of natural kettle lakes and marshes, which ODNR names as Old Indian Lake, Otter Lake, Black Lake, Sheep Pen Lake, Brush Lake and Little Lake. Farmland went under too: in 1875 the state's resident engineer found 11 tracts belonging to named owners lying below the top-water line. Lewistown, the settlement the reservoir is named for, sits on the shore and was never flooded.

Was Indian Lake really a Native American reservation?

Yes, decades before the dam. The 1817 Treaty of Fort Meigs created the 48-square-mile Lewistown Reservation for the Shawnee and an allied Seneca band, led by the Shawnee chief Quatawapea, known to Americans as Colonel Lewis; it was enlarged in 1818 and ceded entirely in the Treaty of Lewistown, July 20, 1831, after which the band moved west and became the core of the Eastern Shawnee Tribe of Oklahoma.

What happened to Sandy Beach Amusement Park?

Opened on May 30, 1924, by Samuel "Pappy" Wilgus and his son French, Sandy Beach grew into "Ohio's Million Dollar Playground," with a wooden coaster and the Minnewawa Dance Hall, billed as the fifth-largest dance hall in the United States. Competition from newer parks and a string of Fourth of July riots starting in 1961 helped close it in 1975; only a footbridge survives, restored in 2014.

Is Indian Lake safe to swim in?

The lake is Ohio EPA "Not Supporting" for recreation, listed for pathogens and habitat alteration, and has documented blue-green algae problems, including a possible harmful bloom investigated at Oldfield Beach in June 2024. Check ODH BeachGuard for current advisories before swimming.

How big is Indian Lake's dam?

The dam is long and low rather than tall: about 19,860 feet (3.76 miles) of earthen embankment, only 16 feet high, carrying State Route 366. Its original 700-foot 1850s spillway was replaced in 2017-2018 with a compact 180-foot labyrinth weir.

Were landowners paid when Indian Lake was flooded?

Some were, slowly. The legislature set aside $20,000 in 1857 to pay for land in the original reservoir, and the state recorded payments in 1858 and 1866. But claims dragged on: an 1870 resolution ordered the flooded land condemned, and in 1875 the resident engineer could find no record that the state had ever bought several of the tracts under water.

When did the Lewistown Reservoir become Indian Lake State Park?

On April 9, 1898, the Ohio General Assembly dedicated the reservoir as a public recreation area named Indian Lake. The state's Division of Conservation ran it as Indian Lake State Park by 1940, and in 1949 it passed to the new Ohio Department of Natural Resources.

Videos about Indian Lake

Short videos we made from the old maps and records. All videos

More Ohio lakes

See them all

Cite this page

Cite this page as:

Cracked Buckeye, "Indian Lake", https://crackedbuckeye.com/lakes/indianlake/, built 2026-11-14, accessed [date].

How to cite · Report a correction · Built 2026-11-14