Deep dives · Ashtabula County, Medina County, Mercer County, Pickaway County, Scioto County, Lawrence County

Elk in Ohio

Elk once ranged across Ohio until the last documented kill, in Ashtabula County in October 1838; a 2026 bill would only study bringing them back.

  • Published

At a glance

FactValue
TypeExtirpated native mammal
CountiesStatewide (last record Ashtabula County)
Last documented wild elk killedOctober 1838, Ashtabula County (1838)
Date in ODNR's wildlife timeline1840 (2016)
Weight of Ohio's native elkup to 800 pounds (2016)
Ohio statusextirpated, state rank SX (2024)
Oldest dated Ohio elkabout 12,000 years, Medina County (2021)
Elk on Ohio farms894 on 24 farms (2022)
Elk on Ohio farms, earlier count395 on 15 farms (2017)
Elk study money in House Bill 641$1,000,000 of $3,000,000 (2026)
Study report deadlineDecember 30, 2028 (2026)
Hearings on House Bill 641one, March 4 (2026)
CWD-positive wild deer in Ohio115 (2026)
Kentucky elk herdover 10,000 (2024)
Elk released in Kentucky1,541 (1997-2002)
Pennsylvania elk herd1,342 (2025)

Overview

Elk, the big wapiti now known mostly from the Rockies, were once found all over Ohio. (source) Their bones turn up in the state's bogs and old lake beds back to the end of the Ice Age, and the settlers who arrived around 1800 still met them in the woods. (source) By the 1830s they were nearly gone; the last one on record was killed in Ashtabula County in October 1838. (source) Since then Ohio has had no wild herd, while Kentucky, West Virginia and other eastern states have rebuilt theirs from western stock. (source) In 2026 an Ohio bill proposed a study of doing the same here, and it has gone no further than one hearing. (source)

The name

The animal goes by two names in the record. Ohio's 19th-century writers called it the elk, and the Cleveland Museum of Natural History's 1942 catalog of Ohio mammals called it the wapiti. (source) The native form of the East was the eastern elk, Cervus canadensis canadensis, the name Enders used for Ohio's former elk in 1930. (source) Kentucky's wildlife department says that eastern form is long extinct, so any restoration in the region has to use a different subspecies, the Rocky Mountain elk. (source)

Native American history

Elk were hunted in Ohio long before there was an Ohio. The Cranberry Prairie elk from Mercer County, a nearly complete skeleton dated to about 9,370 radiocarbon years ago, has a hole through its left shoulder blade that shows no healing; the scientists who described it in 1985 wrote that it very probably was wounded by an Early Archaic hunter, wandered into a shallow lake and died there, though they did not rule out a rutting injury. (source) Two elk skeletons found at Silver Lake in Logan County in 1960 were reported to include one with a projectile point lodged in it; that find has not been dated. (source) (source)

Caleb Atwater, writing in 1838, said that when Circleville was first settled the skeletons of fifty elk lay scattered on the surface, which the Indians had left there. (source) Samuel Hildreth, quoted in the state's 1882 mammal report, wrote of 1797 that the Indians had not quite exterminated the buffalo and the elk. (source)

Stories

Twelve thousand years in a Medina County bog

In 2017 a partial elk skeleton came out of a peat bog near Wadsworth in Medina County. (source) Radiocarbon dates published in 2021 put the animal, a robust male about eight and a half years old, at roughly 12,154 to 11,835 calibrated years before present. (source) The authors called the Tope Elk the first directly dated terminal-Pleistocene elk in Ohio, an animal that lived alongside Late Paleoindian people and within centuries of the last mastodons. (source) Another early elk, the Lattimer Elk from Champaign County, has been dated to about 9,020 radiocarbon years. (source) The Cleveland museum's 1942 catalog said elk bones were on hand from nearly all post-glacial layers, with finds from Ottawa, Sandusky, Erie, Portage, Summit, Cuyahoga and Geauga counties. (source)

Elk in vast numbers

The early written record makes elk common. Atwater wrote that Ohio had once had the bison and the elk in vast numbers all over the state, and that deer, bison, bear and elk were hunted on the site of Cincinnati until Fort Washington was built in 1789. (source) The 1882 state mammal report, drawing on Henry Howe's Historical Collections, noted elk in 1760 in what is now Clark County. (source) The same report quoted the journal of Maj. John Rogers on a march along Lake Erie in January 1761: "Killed in our march this day three bears and two elk." (source)

A footnote beside the last buffalo

The date usually given for Ohio's last elk traces back to a footnote. In his Report on the Zoology of Ohio, dated at Cincinnati on November 1, 1838, Dr. Jared Kirtland wrote in Note 48 that the elk was frequently to be met with in Ashtabula County until within the last six years, and that he had learned from a Col. Harper of that county that one was killed there as recently as October of the present season. (source) That makes the last documented kill October 1838, reported second-hand, with elk common in the county until about 1832. (source) Kirtland does not say more about Harper, and the record does not identify him. (source) Two notes further down the same page, Kirtland quoted Dr. Hildreth's letter on the buffalo: two were killed on the Sandy forks of Symmes' Creek, near the southeastern corner of Jackson County, in 1800, the last heard of in the state. (source)

How 1838 became 1840

Later writers rounded and reread Kirtland's note. Enders, writing for the University of Michigan museum in 1930, said one was killed in Ashtabula County in 1838 and that records of former elk in Ohio are not rare. (source) The Cleveland museum's 1942 catalog said the wapiti had been extinct in the state since about 1840, when the last animals were killed in Ashtabula County, and its footnote cites only Kirtland's 1838 report. (source) ODNR's wildlife history timeline now gives 1840: elk, once found across the state, are gone, and the last report came from Ashtabula County. (source) A 2021 paper in the Ohio Journal of Science, also citing Kirtland, gives 1837. (source) Older and newer sources give still other years: an Athens County history of 1869 said buffalo and elk lasted until about 1800, and a Toledo judge wrote in 1878 that elk disappeared about fifty years before. (source) A Division of Wildlife history says moose, elk and bison were gone by 1843 (source), its Mammals of Ohio field guide says by the 1830s (source), and Outdoor News put the last kill in 1841. (source)

Why they went

The agencies give the same general causes. The Wildlife Management Institute blames unregulated market hunting and landscape-wide habitat change for the loss of elk across the East. (source) ODNR's field guide says Ohio's elk were vanquished by overhunting, habitat loss and expanding human settlements. (source) No count of how many elk were killed in Ohio, or where the last bands lived, has been published; one retired wildlife officer's newspaper history calls the Great Black Swamp the final stronghold of the state's last elk, bears, wolves and lynx, without giving a source. (source)

Antlers in the bay and elk at the zoo

After 1838 Ohio's elk show up mostly as bones and as captives. Museum records list antlers from Eagle Island in Sandusky Bay tagged spring 1915 (source), a humerus fragment found at Mogadore Dam in Portage County in 1937 (source), and the skull of a 15-year-old elk from Cleveland's Brookside Zoo, catalogued in 1916. (source) The Global Biodiversity Information Facility holds only seven elk records for Ohio, all museum specimens, the dated ones from 1896 to 1937, and no observations of a living wild elk. (source) Since then the record holds few confirmed reports of elk running loose in Ohio.

Ohio's elk today live on farms

Ohio does have elk, behind fences. The 2022 Census of Agriculture counted 894 elk on 24 Ohio farms, up from 395 on 15 farms in 2017, and 15 farms sold 213 elk worth $621,000 that year. (source) Captive deer and elk are overseen by the Ohio Department of Agriculture, whose voluntary CWD herd certification program requires fencing, identification, inventories, escape reports and testing of animals over a year old that die. (source) The Wilds, the conservation park on reclaimed mine land in Muskingum County, keeps two Asian deer, the Bactrian deer and Pere David's deer, but no elk. (source) The Bactrian deer is a subspecies of red deer, a close relative of the elk and somewhat smaller than an American elk. (source)

Kentucky's herd across the river

The nearest wild elk to Ohio are in eastern Kentucky. Kentucky released 1,541 elk from Arizona, Kansas, North Dakota, New Mexico, Oregon and Utah between 1997 and 2002, at sites in Harlan, Knott, Leslie, Letcher, Martin, Perry and Pike counties. (source) The first release, on December 17, 1997 at Potato Knob in Perry County, drew about 4,000 people in 61 school buses, according to the department's magazine. (source) One bull from the early releases wandered north to Mason County near the Ohio River; biologists darted it three times as it headed toward Interstate 75, and it died of heat exhaustion. (source) About two-thirds of the elk came from Utah, whose own herds were restocked from Yellowstone. (source)

The start-up money came from odd places. Fines paid by 27 dove hunters caught over bait in Simpson County funded a study, the Rocky Mountain Elk Foundation pledged $1 million in 1997, and a coal company opened a 17,000-acre reclaimed mine site for releases. (source) The 16-county restoration zone covers more than 4.1 million acres, about 80 percent forest and 10 percent active or reclaimed surface mine. (source) Kentucky now estimates its herd at over 10,000 elk (source), up from about 6,500 in 2007. (source) It held its first elk hunt in 2001 and issued 500 permits in 2024; nonresidents, Ohioans included, can draw up to 10 percent, and the 2024 odds for a nonresident bull firearm permit were 1 in 1,102. (source)

The payoff has been real but modest. Kentucky's management plan measured direct spending by elk hunters at $3.21 million in 2013 and $2.79 million in 2014, and said non-hunting elk tourism had shown relatively little growth compared with Pennsylvania, where the Elk Country Visitor Center drew about 411,000 people in 2014. (source) The state logs about 20 elk-vehicle collisions a year against about 3,000 involving deer. (source) Kentucky has since supplied elk to restorations in West Virginia, Missouri, Virginia and Wisconsin. (source) (source) (source)

Pennsylvania nearly failed first

Pennsylvania's restored herd, the oldest in the East, almost did not survive. Its last native elk was shot about 1877; the Game Commission shipped 50 Yellowstone elk at about $30 apiece in 1913 and 95 more in 1915, turned them loose straight off the boxcars, and fielded farmers' complaints about corn raids. (source) By 1930 elk survived only in Cameron and Elk counties, and the herd stayed between 24 and 70 animals into the 1970s. (source) An aerial survey in early 2025 estimated 1,342 elk, and 55,778 people sent 109,780 applications for the 2024 elk licenses. (source) Michigan's seven western elk of 1918 grew to about 1,500 by the early 1960s, then crashed to about 200 by 1975 under poaching and poorer habitat. (source) Arkansas's herd of 1933 reached about 200 by the mid-1950s and then abruptly vanished. (source)

Brainworm and wasting disease

The parasite that worries eastern elk managers rides in white-tailed deer. West Virginia began its herd in December 2016 with 24 elk from Land Between the Lakes on the Tomblin Wildlife Management Area in Logan County, and had about 130 elk by 2024. (source) (source) Of 74 elk that died there from 2016 to early 2025, 54 were killed by brainworm, and the project leader said further imports would wait on a live-animal test for chronic wasting disease. (source) Missouri's herd was started with 34 Kentucky elk at Peck Ranch in May 2011 (source), and calf losses blamed on the same worm had held it to 150 to 200 animals by 2019. (source) In Kentucky about 4 to 6 percent of elk carry it. (source)

Chronic wasting disease is Ohio's own problem. The first Ohio case, announced October 23, 2014, was a captive buck on a Holmes County hunting preserve tied to a Pennsylvania captive-deer operation. (source) The first wild case was a buck shot in Wyandot County, confirmed in December 2020. (source) By June 2026 ODNR counted 115 positive wild deer, nearly all in Wyandot, Marion, Hardin and Allen counties, far from the southeastern hills the elk studies favored. (source) The 2025-26 season found 40, the most yet. (source) Ohio already bars hunters from bringing in high-risk carcass parts of elk and other deer from outside the state. (source)

The 2015 study and the 2024 push

Ohio's modern elk debate rests on a study few people have seen. In 2015 the Division of Wildlife contracted Ohio State University researchers to assess elk habitat (source), and ODNR has said the work found habitat for a limited number of elk in one or more areas of southeast Ohio. (source) A 2023 Marietta Times column named the zones as Coshocton, Tippecanoe, Marietta, Athens North, Athens West, Ironton and Shawnee, with the Marietta area the largest. (source) The same column counted more than 4,500 signatures on an online petition and more than 8,000 members in an Ohio Elk Hunting group on Facebook. (source)

In 2024 State Sen. Shane Wilkin backed a citizen group's push and called an October 30 meeting to gather views. (source) Afterward the Division of Wildlife issued a position statement opposing reintroduction, citing what it called an unacceptable risk to motorists and crop damage. (source) Lawrence County Commissioner DeAnna Holliday, who went to the Columbus meeting, described releasing elk in pockets that would merge into a herd. (source) Scioto County's commissioners also endorsed a plan to bring a small number of western elk to a fenced acclimation area in the southeast; the published account of their vote carries no date. (source)

Trails and Tails

The only elk bill in the statehouse is House Bill 641, the Trails and Tails Act, introduced January 12, 2026 by Rep. Justin Pizzulli, a Scioto County Republican, with no cosponsors. (source) It appropriates $3 million: $2 million to study side-by-side and all-purpose vehicle trails and $1 million to study the feasibility of reintroducing elk. (source) The elk study would look at habitat, ecological effects, disease, source herds, management including possible limited hunting seasons, and costs, with a report due December 30, 2028; it would not put a single elk on the ground. (source) Its disease section names chronic wasting disease and bovine tuberculosis and other transmissible diseases, but not brainworm. (source)

Pizzulli told the House Natural Resources Committee that the bill began with conversations back home and that he had attached a 68-page Ohio State study concluding that reintroducing elk is feasible; the attachment is not posted with his testimony. (source) He told Fox 8 that if a modest study could lead to tens of millions in economic growth, it was worth a serious look. (source) ODNR's reply was that elk are susceptible to CWD, that elk in other states are testing positive, and that the disease must be weighed. (source) The bill had its first hearing, sponsor testimony only, on March 4, 2026, and no committee vote has followed. (source)

What the law says now

Because elk are gone rather than scarce, they sit in a different legal box from Ohio's rare animals. ODNR lists the elk as extirpated, with bison, marten, lynx, cougar, porcupine and gray wolf. (source) The state's endangered-species rule, effective July 6, 2026, names the black bear and five bats among mammals and does not include the elk. (source)

Myths and the record

"The last wild elk was killed in Ashtabula County in 1840." The primary record, Kirtland's report of November 1, 1838, describes an Ashtabula County elk killed in October 1838. (source) The 1840 date appears first in a 1942 summary that cites only Kirtland. (source)

"Ohio lawmakers voted to bring elk back." House Bill 641 would fund a study by the Division of Wildlife; it releases no elk and has not had a committee vote. (source) The Ohio Newsroom reported the elk study as $1.5 million (source); the bill text says $1 million. (source)

"Kentucky has 15,000 elk." Kentucky's own 2024 report puts the herd at over 10,000, by two population models. (source) The Ironton Tribune's figure of about 1,700 was too low. (source)

"Kentucky has no CWD." Kentucky found it in a wild deer in Ballard County in 2023, in a captive facility in 2024 and in a second wild deer in Pulaski County in 2025; the department reports no case in more than 1,000 elk tested since 2002. (source)

"Muskingum means elk's eye." Mahr's 1957 study of Ohio Indian place names called that reading a folk etymology and traced the name to a Shawnee word for swampy, soggy land. (source)

"Ohio has no elk." No wild ones, but 894 on farms in 2022. (source)

Timeline

  • About 12,000 years ago: The Tope Elk, a bull about 8.5 years old, dies in a bog near Wadsworth, Medina County. (source)
  • About 9,370 radiocarbon years ago: An elk with an unhealed hole in its shoulder blade dies at Cranberry Prairie, Mercer County. (source)
  • 1760: Elk are noted in what is now Clark County. (source)
  • 1761: In January Maj. John Rogers's party kills three bears and two elk on a march along Lake Erie. (source)
  • 1800: The last two buffalo heard of in Ohio are killed in Jackson County. (source)
  • About 1832: Elk stop being frequently met with in Ashtabula County. (source)
  • 1838: In October an elk is killed in Ashtabula County, the last documented in Ohio; Kirtland reports it on November 1. (source)
  • 1877: Pennsylvania's last native elk is shot, about this year. (source)
  • 1913: Pennsylvania brings in 50 Yellowstone elk. (source)
  • 1916: The skull of a 15-year-old elk from Cleveland's Brookside Zoo enters the museum record. (source)
  • 1960: Two elk skeletons are found at Silver Lake, Logan County. (source)
  • 1997: On December 17 Kentucky releases its first elk at Potato Knob, Perry County. (source)
  • 2001: Kentucky holds its first elk hunt. (source)
  • 2014: On October 23 Ohio announces its first chronic wasting disease case, a captive buck in Holmes County. (source)
  • 2015: Ohio State researchers complete an elk habitat assessment for the Division of Wildlife. (source)
  • 2016: West Virginia releases its first 24 elk in December. (source)
  • 2017: The Tope Elk is found near Wadsworth. (source)
  • 2020: CWD is confirmed in a wild Ohio deer, in Wyandot County, in December. (source)
  • 2022: The Census of Agriculture counts 894 elk on 24 Ohio farms. (source)
  • 2024: Sen. Shane Wilkin convenes an October 30 meeting on elk; the Division of Wildlife then states its opposition. (source)
  • 2026: House Bill 641 is introduced January 12 and heard once, on March 4. (source)
  • 2026: ODNR counts 115 CWD-positive wild deer as of June. (source)

Sources

Questions

When was the last wild elk killed in Ohio?

The last documented wild elk in Ohio was killed in Ashtabula County in October 1838. Dr. Jared Kirtland reported it in his zoology report for the state geological survey, dated November 1, 1838, on the word of a Col. Harper of that county, and added that elk had been frequently met with there until about six years earlier. The often repeated year 1840 comes from later summaries of that same note; other printed dates run from about 1800 to 1843.

Are there elk in Ohio now?

There is no wild elk herd in Ohio. Ohio's elk are on farms: the 2022 Census of Agriculture counted 894 elk on 24 Ohio farms, up from 395 elk on 15 farms in 2017. The Ohio Division of Wildlife lists the elk as extirpated, gone from the state, rather than endangered.

Is Ohio bringing elk back?

Not yet. House Bill 641, introduced January 12, 2026 by Rep. Justin Pizzulli of Scioto County, would pay for a study of whether elk could be reintroduced; it would not release any elk. It had one committee hearing, on March 4, 2026, with sponsor testimony only. In late 2024 the Ohio Division of Wildlife issued a position statement opposing reintroduction because of the risk to motorists and crop damage.

How much would the Ohio elk study cost?

House Bill 641 appropriates $3 million from the General Revenue Fund: $1 million for the elk feasibility study and $2 million for a study of side-by-side and all-purpose vehicle trails. The Division of Wildlife would have to report by December 30, 2028. Some news reports gave the elk study as $1.5 million, which does not match the bill text.

Where in Ohio could elk live?

A 2015 assessment by Ohio State University for the Division of Wildlife found habitat for a limited number of elk in southeast and east-central Ohio. Press accounts of that study name zones around Coshocton, Tippecanoe, Marietta, Athens North, Athens West, Ironton and Shawnee, with the Marietta area the largest. Crop damage and vehicle collisions were the main problems it identified.

How many elk does Kentucky have?

Kentucky's wildlife department estimates its herd at over 10,000 elk, the largest east of the Mississippi, grown from 1,541 elk released from six western states between 1997 and 2002. Figures of 15,000 or 16,000 sometimes repeated in Ohio news are higher than the agency's estimate. Ohioans can apply for Kentucky elk permits as nonresidents, but in 2024 the odds for a nonresident bull firearm permit were 1 in 1,102.

Does Muskingum mean elk's eye?

Probably not. The linguist August Mahr wrote in 1957 that the elk's eye reading, built from the Delaware words for elk and eye, looks like a folk etymology. He thought the name more likely comes from a Shawnee word for swampy, soggy land.

How old are the oldest elk bones found in Ohio?

The Tope Elk, a partial skeleton found in 2017 in a peat bog near Wadsworth in Medina County, has been radiocarbon dated to about 12,000 years ago, the first directly dated elk of that age in Ohio. A nearly complete elk from Cranberry Prairie in Mercer County, about 9,370 radiocarbon years old, has a hole through its shoulder blade that its describers thought was very probably made by an Early Archaic hunter.

What diseases are a concern for elk in Ohio?

Chronic wasting disease is the one Ohio officials name first: it has been found in 115 wild Ohio deer as of June 2026, all in the north-central and northwest counties, and ODNR says elk elsewhere are testing positive. House Bill 641's study would cover CWD and bovine tuberculosis. In West Virginia's restored herd, brainworm, a parasite carried harmlessly by white-tailed deer, caused 54 of 74 elk deaths from 2016 to early 2025.

More deep dives

See them all

Cite this page

Cite this page as:

Cracked Buckeye, "Elk in Ohio", https://crackedbuckeye.com/deep-dives/elk-in-ohio/, built 2026-11-14, accessed [date].

How to cite · Report a correction · Built 2026-11-14