Lower Salem

How Lower Salem began

Lower Salem, in Salem Township in the northern hill country of Washington County, was laid out in 1850 by James Stanley as 'Salem' when a plank road connecting it to Marietta seemed likely to make it a substantial town; the road did not pay and its boards were left to rot, but the village it started kept growing, settled predominantly by German immigrants. By 1881 it had a hotel, livery stable, grist-mill, tannery, six stores, and four churches. It once also supported a doctor's office, an armory, and a gas station, most now closed though the buildings remain. Its population peaked at 198 in 1880; the 2020 census recorded just 75 residents, and the village today is home to Salem-Liberty Elementary School.

Platted 1850, by James Stanley, on the strength of a planned plank road to Marietta; resident stockholders William Thomas, Madison R. Morse, H. McGee, and Moses True.

Where the name comes from

In 1881 the village was called simply Salem, after Salem Township, which the county history says was named because many first settlers came from near Salem, Massachusetts; the history does not say when or why 'Lower' was added.

Before the town

No village, mound, trail or treaty site specific to Lower Salem is recorded.

Timeline

1. 1850 — James Stanley lays out the village on the strength of a planned plank road from Marietta; the toll-house at the road's terminus is the village's first building, and the first house is built by Benjamin Hovey.
2. 1859 — Palmer Lodge No. 351, I.O.O.F., is organized at John A. Palmer's house in April, chartered in May and holds its first meeting at the Valley House in July; it meets in Blake's store.
3. 1873 — A two-story brick school building is built at a cost of over $3,000, with W. R. and Talma Goddard its first teachers (the history says 'eight years ago' in 1881).
4. 1877 — The Baptist church of Lower Salem is organized under Rev. J. D. Riley with seventeen members, at first worshipping in the old Presbyterian church building; a new frame building goes up in the village over the winter of 1880-81.
5. 1878 — The Protestant Methodists complete their church in Salem on land given by H. Magee.
6. 1880 — The village's population peaks at 198 residents; by this date it has a hotel, livery stable, grist-mill, a saw- and planing-mill, a tannery, six grocery and dry goods stores, a tobacco packing house, two carriage shops, three blacksmith shops, two shoe stores, a harness shop, a cigar factory, and four churches, along with a two-story brick school building erected about 1873.
7. 1880 — In October John Kiggens, sinking a well at the upper end of Salem village, strikes a vein of mineral water at 684 feet that boils over every hour or so and every day or two throws a stream 150 feet high.
8. 1900 — The population is 190, down from 198 in 1880.
9. 1960 — The population is 143, the last count above 110.
10. 2010 — The village's population stands at 86 residents.
11. 2020 — The census records 75 residents, a 12.8 percent decline from 2010.

Stories

A road that failed and a village that didn't

Salem village exists because of a road that never paid for itself. In 1850, James Stanley laid out the village on the strength of a planned plank road connecting it to Marietta, a corduroy-style timber road that its resident stockholders -- William Thomas, Madison R. Morse, H. McGee, and Moses True -- believed would make the place 'quite a fair sized town.' A toll-house was built at the road's terminus, the first structure in the new village. But the plank road did not pay, and its boards were simply allowed to rot in place. The village it had been built to serve, however, kept growing anyway: by 1881 it supported a hotel, a livery stable, a grist-mill, a tannery, six grocery and dry goods stores, a cigar factory, and four churches, all serving a countryside settled heavily by German immigrant farmers. The road that was meant to build the town failed completely; the town built itself regardless.

A main street that outlived its stores

For much of its history, Lower Salem was a genuinely busy little crossroads: a hotel for travelers on the Old Plank Road, a doctor's office, an armory, Wagner's General Store, and later a gas station and auto parts shop, all serving a German immigrant farming community that had grown up steadily since the village's 1850 platting. Nearly all of it has closed in the years since -- the storefronts remain standing along the main street, empty rather than demolished, a common pattern in small Washington County villages whose population has fallen by more than half since their nineteenth-century peak. What has stayed active is Salem-Liberty Elementary School, serving about 80 students from the Fort Frye Local School District, keeping the village a working part of the surrounding township even as its commercial life has faded.

The well that boiled over

In October 1880 John Kiggens was sinking a well in the upper end of Salem village, on the right bank of Duck Creek, when at 684 feet he struck a vein of mineral water. Pushed by gas, the water boiled over the top of the well about once every hour, and at irregular intervals averaging perhaps forty-eight hours the force of the gas threw a vertical stream a hundred and fifty feet above the mouth. The 1881 county history says the display regularly drew its quota of spectators when a blast was expected. The water had a strong odor and tasted like brine, though it was reported that no salt could be got from it by boiling, and many in the neighbourhood believed it of great medicinal virtue. The historian took the supply of gas as a sign that petroleum lay somewhere nearby, though oil had not yet been found in paying quantities in the township.

Local history sources: en.wikipedia.org · en.wikipedia.org · archive.org · archive.org

No water-system data is linked to Lower Salem's ZIP codes yet.

Elections for office

Winners in bold. Results from the county board of elections' official canvass unless marked.

Auditor of State record

• No fiscal caution, watch or emergency on the Auditor of State's lists.
• Basic Audit, 2023 to 2024, released 2025-07-15

Cite this page