Election 2024

Justice of the Supreme Court (Full term commencing 1-1-2025)

November 5, 2024 · general election · 2 candidates with a page

Correct this page · hello@crackedbuckeye.com

The candidates

Listed alphabetically by surname. Ohio rotates the order candidates appear in by precinct, so no order on this page is the order on a ballot.

Michael P. Donnelly

Democratic · Former Justice of the Supreme Court of Ohio, 2019–2024

  • Civil litigation lawyer, 1997 to 2004, first at an insurance-defense firm, then representing injured workers and other plaintiffs
  • Assistant Cuyahoga County Prosecutor, 1992 to 1997
  • Member, Supreme Court of Ohio Commission on Professionalism, 2007 to 2012; chair in his final year

5 of 11 sections researched · 13 sources

Megan Shanahan

Republican · Justice of the Supreme Court of Ohio, since 2025

  • Felony assistant prosecutor in Butler and Hamilton counties
  • Bachelor's degree, Kent State University, 1995
  • Law degree, University of Cincinnati College of Law, 2000

5 of 11 sections researched · 18 sources

Michael P. Donnelly

Coverage, by section5 of 11 sections researched.Profile: 13 entriesOn the ballot: 0 entriesWhere they stand: Not yet researchedWhat they have said, checked: Not yet researchedRecord in office: 4 entriesMoney: Not yet researchedFinancial interests: Not yet researchedPolling and approval: Not yet researchedElections: 2 entriesEndorsements: Not yet researchedSources: 11 entries5 of 11 sections researched · 13 sources
Coverage, by section5 of 11 sections researched.Source: Cracked Buckeye coverage record for Michael P. Donnelly, 5 of 11 sections researched · as of 2026-09-25 · Download this chart
The numbers behind this figure, as a table
Coverage, by section
SectionState
profileresearched
ballotresearched
positionsnot researched
claimsnot researched
recordresearched
moneynot researched
interestsnot researched
pollingnot researched
electionsresearched
endorsementsnot researched
sourcesresearched

Megan Shanahan

Coverage, by section5 of 11 sections researched.Profile: 10 entriesOn the ballot: 0 entriesWhere they stand: Not yet researchedWhat they have said, checked: Not yet researchedRecord in office: 5 entriesMoney: Not yet researchedFinancial interests: Not yet researchedPolling and approval: Not yet researchedElections: 1 entryEndorsements: Not yet researchedSources: 13 entries5 of 11 sections researched · 18 sources
Coverage, by section5 of 11 sections researched.Source: Cracked Buckeye coverage record for Megan Shanahan, 5 of 11 sections researched · as of 2026-09-24 · Download this chart
The numbers behind this figure, as a table
Coverage, by section
SectionState
profileresearched
ballotresearched
positionsnot researched
claimsnot researched
recordresearched
moneynot researched
interestsnot researched
pollingnot researched
electionsresearched
endorsementsnot researched
sourcesresearched

The race in pictures

Polls, Justice of the Supreme Court (Full term commencing 1-1-2025), as publishedNo poll of this race is on file yet.None found in the records checked
Polls, Justice of the Supreme Court (Full term commencing 1-1-2025), as publishedNo poll of this race is on file yet.Source: fec.gov · as of 2026-11-03 · Download this chart
The numbers behind this figure, as a table
Polls, Justice of the Supreme Court (Full term commencing 1-1-2025), as published
Status
None found in the records checked
Money, raised, spent and cash on hand, as filedRaised, as filed: Donnelly not yet researched, Shanahan not yet researched.RaisedDonnelly (D)Michael P. Donnelly: raised not yet researchedNot yet researchedShanahan (R)Megan Shanahan: raised not yet researchedNot yet researchedSpentDonnelly (D)Michael P. Donnelly: spent not yet researchedNot yet researchedShanahan (R)Megan Shanahan: spent not yet researchedNot yet researchedCash on handDonnelly (D)Michael P. Donnelly: cash on hand not yet researchedNot yet researchedShanahan (R)Megan Shanahan: cash on hand not yet researchedNot yet researched
Money, raised, spent and cash on hand, as filedRaised, as filed: Donnelly not yet researched, Shanahan not yet researched.Source: FEC filings · as of 2026-11-03 · Download this chart
The numbers behind this figure, as a table
Money, raised, spent and cash on hand, as filed
GroupItemUSDNote
RaisedDonnelly (D)Not yet researched
RaisedShanahan (R)Not yet researched
SpentDonnelly (D)Not yet researched
SpentShanahan (R)Not yet researched
Cash on handDonnelly (D)Not yet researched
Cash on handShanahan (R)Not yet researched
Jump to a candidate

Where they stand

Their own words, by issue, with the date, the venue and the link. A paraphrase is marked as one.

Michael P. Donnelly

Not yet researched

Megan Shanahan

Not yet researched

What they have said, checked

Newest first. Each check is shown in the checker's own rating word, with their name, the date and the link.

Michael P. Donnelly

Not yet researched

Megan Shanahan

Not yet researched

Record in office

Dated actions. Any evaluation of an action is printed with the name of whoever made it and the link.

Record in office, dated entries, both candidates on one axis9 record entries from 2020 to 2026; 9 of them rulings; 5 offices held on the record.20102020Donnelly (D)Judge, Cuyahoga County Court of Common Pleas, General Division, 2005-01-03 to 2018Justice of the Supreme Court of Ohio, 2019-01-01 to 2024-12-312020-06-16 (ruling): Wrote the Supreme Court of Ohio's opinion in Bey v. Rasawehr, 2020-Ohio-3301, which held that a civil stalking protection order barring a ma2022-01-14 (ruling): Wrote the Supreme Court of Ohio's majority opinion in Adams v. DeWine, 2022-Ohio-89, which held the General Assembly's 2021 congressional di2022-12-07 (ruling): Wrote the Supreme Court of Ohio's majority opinion in State ex rel. Ohio History Connection v. Moundbuilders Country Club Co., 2022-Ohio-4342024-12-10 (ruling): Wrote the Supreme Court of Ohio's opinion in Stull v. Summa Health System, 2024-Ohio-5718, which held that ambiguities in a hospital's affidShanahan (R)Judge, Hamilton County Municipal Court, 2011 to 2015Judge, Hamilton County Court of Common Pleas, 2015-04-13 to 2024-12-31Justice of the Supreme Court of Ohio, 2025-01-01 to present2025-12-24 (ruling): Wrote the Supreme Court of Ohio's majority opinion in VVF Intervest LLC v. Harris, 2025-Ohio-5680, which held that Ohio's commercial activit2026-04-02 (ruling): Wrote the Supreme Court of Ohio's majority opinion in Faith Ranch & Farms Fund, Inc. v. PNC Bank, 2026-Ohio-1145, which held that a 1953 Har2026-06-18 (ruling): Wrote the Supreme Court of Ohio's majority opinion in Bitounis v. Interactive Brokers LLC, 2026-Ohio-2268, which held that an online brokera2026-07-10 (ruling): Wrote the Supreme Court of Ohio's majority opinion in State v. Polizzi, 2026-Ohio-2588, which affirmed a 358-month aggregate prison sentence2026-08-27 (ruling): Wrote the Supreme Court of Ohio's unanimous opinion in Allied Health & Chiropractic LLC v. State, 2026-Ohio-3308, which held that the Genera
Record in office, dated entries, both candidates on one axis9 record entries from 2020 to 2026; 9 of them rulings; 5 offices held on the record.Source: Cracked Buckeye person record for Donnelly (D) and Shanahan (R), 9 dated entries · as of 2026-08-27 · Download this chart
The numbers behind this figure, as a table
Record in office, dated entries, both candidates on one axis
PersonDateKindEntry
Donnelly (D)2005-01-03officeJudge, Cuyahoga County Court of Common Pleas, General Division
Donnelly (D)2019-01-01officeJustice of the Supreme Court of Ohio
Donnelly (D)2020-06-16ruling2020-06-16 (ruling): Wrote the Supreme Court of Ohio's opinion in Bey v. Rasawehr, 2020-Ohio-3301, which held that a civil stalking protection order barring a ma
Donnelly (D)2022-01-14ruling2022-01-14 (ruling): Wrote the Supreme Court of Ohio's majority opinion in Adams v. DeWine, 2022-Ohio-89, which held the General Assembly's 2021 congressional di
Donnelly (D)2022-12-07ruling2022-12-07 (ruling): Wrote the Supreme Court of Ohio's majority opinion in State ex rel. Ohio History Connection v. Moundbuilders Country Club Co., 2022-Ohio-434
Donnelly (D)2024-12-10ruling2024-12-10 (ruling): Wrote the Supreme Court of Ohio's opinion in Stull v. Summa Health System, 2024-Ohio-5718, which held that ambiguities in a hospital's affid
Shanahan (R)2011officeJudge, Hamilton County Municipal Court
Shanahan (R)2015-04-13officeJudge, Hamilton County Court of Common Pleas
Shanahan (R)2025-01-01officeJustice of the Supreme Court of Ohio
Shanahan (R)2025-12-24ruling2025-12-24 (ruling): Wrote the Supreme Court of Ohio's majority opinion in VVF Intervest LLC v. Harris, 2025-Ohio-5680, which held that Ohio's commercial activit
Shanahan (R)2026-04-02ruling2026-04-02 (ruling): Wrote the Supreme Court of Ohio's majority opinion in Faith Ranch & Farms Fund, Inc. v. PNC Bank, 2026-Ohio-1145, which held that a 1953 Har
Shanahan (R)2026-06-18ruling2026-06-18 (ruling): Wrote the Supreme Court of Ohio's majority opinion in Bitounis v. Interactive Brokers LLC, 2026-Ohio-2268, which held that an online brokera
Shanahan (R)2026-07-10ruling2026-07-10 (ruling): Wrote the Supreme Court of Ohio's majority opinion in State v. Polizzi, 2026-Ohio-2588, which affirmed a 358-month aggregate prison sentence
Shanahan (R)2026-08-27ruling2026-08-27 (ruling): Wrote the Supreme Court of Ohio's unanimous opinion in Allied Health & Chiropractic LLC v. State, 2026-Ohio-3308, which held that the Genera

Michael P. Donnelly

  1. December 10, 2024 · ruling

    Wrote the Supreme Court of Ohio's opinion in Stull v. Summa Health System, 2024-Ohio-5718, which held that ambiguities in a hospital's affidavit do not alone decide whether a resident physician's file is covered by the peer-review privilege, and sent the case back for the trial court to review the file in camera.

    Sources: Stull v. Summa Health Sys., 2024-Ohio-5718 · Opinions by Justice Michael P. Donnelly

  2. December 7, 2022 · ruling

    Wrote the Supreme Court of Ohio's majority opinion in State ex rel. Ohio History Connection v. Moundbuilders Country Club Co., 2022-Ohio-4345, which allowed the Ohio History Connection to take the country club's lease on the Octagon Earthworks in Newark by eminent domain for a public park.

    Sources: State ex rel. Ohio History Connection v. Moundbuilders Country Club Co., 2022-Ohio-4345 · State Can Acquire Octagon Earthworks From Country Club · Opinions by Justice Michael P. Donnelly

  3. January 14, 2022 · ruling

    Wrote the Supreme Court of Ohio's majority opinion in Adams v. DeWine, 2022-Ohio-89, which held the General Assembly's 2021 congressional district plan invalid under Article XIX of the Ohio Constitution and ordered a new plan within 30 days.

    Sources: Adams v. DeWine, 2022-Ohio-89 · Opinions by Justice Michael P. Donnelly

  4. June 16, 2020 · ruling

    Wrote the Supreme Court of Ohio's opinion in Bey v. Rasawehr, 2020-Ohio-3301, which held that a civil stalking protection order barring a man's future internet posts about two relatives was a prior restraint that violated the First Amendment.

    Sources: Bey v. Rasawehr, 2020-Ohio-3301 · Court’s Ban on Social Media Future Postings about Relatives Unconstitutional · Opinions by Justice Michael P. Donnelly

Megan Shanahan

  1. August 27, 2026 · ruling

    Wrote the Supreme Court of Ohio's unanimous opinion in Allied Health & Chiropractic LLC v. State, 2026-Ohio-3308, which held that the General Assembly's later amendments to two laws limiting solicitation of crime and accident victims, first enacted in the 2020-2021 budget bill, cured any one-subject-rule violation.

    Sources: Allied Health & Chiropractic LLC v. State, 2026-Ohio-3308 · Revised Laws on Soliciting Crime and Accident Victims Properly Enacted

  2. July 10, 2026 · ruling

    Wrote the Supreme Court of Ohio's majority opinion in State v. Polizzi, 2026-Ohio-2588, which affirmed a 358-month aggregate prison sentence and held that Ohio sentencing law permits, but does not require, a trial court to consider the aggregate term when deciding whether to impose consecutive sentences.

    Sources: State v. Polizzi, 2026-Ohio-2588 · Court Affirms Nearly 30-Year Prison Sentence for Teacher’s Sex Offenses

  3. June 18, 2026 · ruling

    Wrote the Supreme Court of Ohio's majority opinion in Bitounis v. Interactive Brokers LLC, 2026-Ohio-2268, which held that an online brokerage performing routine functions after its customer's unlawful sale of securities did not participate in or aid that sale under R.C. 1707.43(A).

    Sources: Bitounis v. Interactive Brokers LLC, 2026-Ohio-2268 · Online Brokerage Not Responsible for Trader's $25 Million Loss

  4. April 2, 2026 · ruling

    Wrote the Supreme Court of Ohio's majority opinion in Faith Ranch & Farms Fund, Inc. v. PNC Bank, 2026-Ohio-1145, which held that a 1953 Harrison County deed reserving the right to mine coal or other minerals did not reserve the oil and gas rights.

    Sources: Faith Ranch & Farms Fund, Inc. v. PNC Bank, Natl. Assn., 2026-Ohio-1145 · Deed's Reference to 'Other Minerals' Did Not Include Oil and Gas Rights

  5. December 24, 2025 · ruling

    Wrote the Supreme Court of Ohio's majority opinion in VVF Intervest LLC v. Harris, 2025-Ohio-5680, which held that Ohio's commercial activity tax applied to bar soap made in Kansas and received by the purchaser at a Columbus warehouse, reversing a Board of Tax Appeals refund.

    Sources: VVF Intervest LLC v. Harris, 2025-Ohio-5680 · Commercial Activity Tax Applies to Soap Bars Warehoused in Ohio

Money

Totals and donors exactly as filed with the FEC or the Ohio Secretary of State, each figure with its filing link.

Itemized contributions from inside Ohio, share of all itemizedNo filing in this race breaks itemized contributions down by state.None found in the records checked
Itemized contributions from inside Ohio, share of all itemizedNo filing in this race breaks itemized contributions down by state.Source: fec.gov · as of 2026-11-03 · Download this chart
The numbers behind this figure, as a table
Itemized contributions from inside Ohio, share of all itemized
Status
None found in the records checked

Michael P. Donnelly

Where the money went, as filedNo campaign finance filing is on file for Michael P. Donnelly in this race yet.None found in the records checked
Where the money went, as filedNo campaign finance filing is on file for Michael P. Donnelly in this race yet.Source: fec.gov · as of 2026-11-03 · Download this chart
The numbers behind this figure, as a table
Where the money went, as filed
Status
None found in the records checked

Totals as filed

Not yet researched

Top donors, as filed

Not yet researched

Outside spending

Not yet researched

In-state share

Not yet researched

Megan Shanahan

Where the money went, as filedNo campaign finance filing is on file for Megan Shanahan in this race yet.None found in the records checked
Where the money went, as filedNo campaign finance filing is on file for Megan Shanahan in this race yet.Source: fec.gov · as of 2026-11-03 · Download this chart
The numbers behind this figure, as a table
Where the money went, as filed
Status
None found in the records checked

Totals as filed

Not yet researched

Top donors, as filed

Not yet researched

Outside spending

Not yet researched

In-state share

Not yet researched

The result

Past election results, share of the vote1 prior race on file across 2 candidates; none on file for Shanahan.Donnelly2018 Supreme CourtMichael P. Donnelly, Justice of the Supreme Court (Full term commencing 1-1-2019): won, 61.0%61.0%ShanahanMegan Shanahan: no prior race on fileno prior race on file
Past election results, share of the vote1 prior race on file across 2 candidates; none on file for Shanahan.Source: Ohio Secretary of State, official canvass, 2018 · as of 2018 · Download this chart
The numbers behind this figure, as a table
Past election results, share of the vote
GroupItemPCTNote
Donnelly2018 Supreme Court61.0
Shanahanno prior race on file

Megan Shanahan · certified 2024-12-02 · turnout 71.71

CandidateVotesShare
Megan Shanahan3,025,88455.6%
Michael P. Donnelly2,415,50744.4%

Sources: 2024 Ohio elections · 2024 United States presidential election in Ohio · Ohio boards of elections still review and audit results after their certification · LaRose certifies official 2024 general election results

Sources

Data from Wikipedia, CC BY-SA 4.0: 2024 Ohio elections · 2024 United States presidential election in Ohio · Michael P. Donnelly (judge) · 2018 Ohio elections · 2018 Ohio gubernatorial election · Megan E. Shanahan

  1. 2024 Ohio elections · Wikipedia · accessed 2026-09-24
  2. 2024 General Election Candidates · Franklin County Board of Elections · accessed 2026-09-24
  3. Franklin's Official Canvass - Group Detail, 2024 General Election, November 5, 2024 (Franklin County only) · Franklin County Board of Elections · 2024-11-19 · accessed 2026-09-24
  4. 2024 United States presidential election in Ohio · Wikipedia · accessed 2026-09-24
  5. Ohio boards of elections still review and audit results after their certification · The Statehouse News Bureau · 2024-12-10 · accessed 2026-09-24
  6. LaRose certifies official 2024 general election results · The Highland County Press · 2024-12-03 · accessed 2026-09-24
  7. Michael P. Donnelly · Supreme Court of Ohio · accessed 2026-09-24
  8. Michael P. Donnelly (judge) · Wikipedia · accessed 2026-09-24
  9. Stull v. Summa Health Sys., 2024-Ohio-5718 · Supreme Court of Ohio · 2024-12-10 · accessed 2026-09-24
  10. Opinions by Justice Michael P. Donnelly · Supreme Court of Ohio · accessed 2026-09-24
  11. State ex rel. Ohio History Connection v. Moundbuilders Country Club Co., 2022-Ohio-4345 · Supreme Court of Ohio · 2022-12-07 · accessed 2026-09-24
  12. State Can Acquire Octagon Earthworks From Country Club · Court News Ohio (Supreme Court of Ohio) · 2022-12-07 · accessed 2026-09-24
  13. Adams v. DeWine, 2022-Ohio-89 · Supreme Court of Ohio · 2022-01-14 · accessed 2026-09-24
  14. Bey v. Rasawehr, 2020-Ohio-3301 · Supreme Court of Ohio · 2020-06-16 · accessed 2026-09-24
  15. Court’s Ban on Social Media Future Postings about Relatives Unconstitutional · Court News Ohio (Supreme Court of Ohio) · 2020-06-16 · accessed 2026-09-24
  16. 2018 Ohio elections · Wikipedia · accessed 2026-09-25
  17. 2018 Ohio gubernatorial election · Wikipedia · accessed 2026-09-25
  18. Justice Megan E. Shanahan · Supreme Court of Ohio · accessed 2026-09-24
  19. Megan E. Shanahan · Wikipedia · accessed 2026-09-24
  20. Justice Megan E. Shanahan Celebrated as Supreme Court's 165th Justice · Court News Ohio (Supreme Court of Ohio) · 2025-03-21 · accessed 2026-09-24
  21. Allied Health & Chiropractic LLC v. State, 2026-Ohio-3308 · Supreme Court of Ohio · 2026-08-27 · accessed 2026-09-24
  22. Revised Laws on Soliciting Crime and Accident Victims Properly Enacted · Court News Ohio (Supreme Court of Ohio) · 2026-08-27 · accessed 2026-09-24
  23. State v. Polizzi, 2026-Ohio-2588 · Supreme Court of Ohio · 2026-07-10 · accessed 2026-09-24
  24. Court Affirms Nearly 30-Year Prison Sentence for Teacher’s Sex Offenses · Court News Ohio (Supreme Court of Ohio) · 2026-07-10 · accessed 2026-09-24
  25. Bitounis v. Interactive Brokers LLC, 2026-Ohio-2268 · Supreme Court of Ohio · 2026-06-18 · accessed 2026-09-24
  26. Online Brokerage Not Responsible for Trader's $25 Million Loss · Court News Ohio (Supreme Court of Ohio) · 2026-06-18 · accessed 2026-09-24
  27. Faith Ranch & Farms Fund, Inc. v. PNC Bank, Natl. Assn., 2026-Ohio-1145 · Supreme Court of Ohio · 2026-04-02 · accessed 2026-09-24
  28. Deed's Reference to 'Other Minerals' Did Not Include Oil and Gas Rights · Court News Ohio (Supreme Court of Ohio) · 2026-04-02 · accessed 2026-09-24
  29. VVF Intervest LLC v. Harris, 2025-Ohio-5680 · Supreme Court of Ohio · 2025-12-24 · accessed 2026-09-24
  30. Commercial Activity Tax Applies to Soap Bars Warehoused in Ohio · Court News Ohio (Supreme Court of Ohio) · 2025-12-24 · accessed 2026-09-24

Quick answers

When was the 2024 Justice of the Supreme Court (Full term commencing 1-1-2025) election in Ohio?

The election for Justice of the Supreme Court (Full term commencing 1-1-2025) was held on November 5, 2024.

Who ran for Justice of the Supreme Court (Full term commencing 1-1-2025) in 2024?

On the ballot for Justice of the Supreme Court (Full term commencing 1-1-2025), in surname order: Michael P. Donnelly (Democratic), Megan Shanahan (Republican).

Who won the 2024 Justice of the Supreme Court (Full term commencing 1-1-2025) election?

Megan Shanahan won the election for Justice of the Supreme Court (Full term commencing 1-1-2025). Results as certified: Michael P. Donnelly 44.4%, Megan Shanahan 55.6%.

Cite and data

Cite this page as:

Cracked Buckeye, "Justice of the Supreme Court (Full term commencing 1-1-2025), 2024", https://crackedbuckeye.com/election/2024/supreme-court-jan-1-2025/, built 2026-11-03, accessed [date].

How to cite · Report a correction · Built 2026-11-03