Election 2018

Justice of the Supreme Court (Full term commencing 1-2-2019)

November 6, 2018 · general election · 2 candidates with a page

Correct this page · hello@crackedbuckeye.com

The candidates

Listed alphabetically by surname. Ohio rotates the order candidates appear in by precinct, so no order on this page is the order on a ballot.

Mary DeGenaro

Republican · Former Justice of the Supreme Court of Ohio, 2018–2019

  • Law clerk to Judge George Washington White, U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Ohio, after graduating law school
  • Private legal practice for 14 years before becoming a judge
  • Bachelor of Arts, Youngstown State University, 1983

5 of 11 sections researched · 7 sources

Melody J. Stewart

Democratic · Former Justice of the Supreme Court of Ohio, 2019–2025

  • Worked as a music teacher, a health care management administrator and a civil defense litigator
  • Lecturer, adjunct instructor, assistant dean and faculty member, Cleveland State University law school
  • Taught at the University of Toledo College of Law and Ursuline College; director of student services, Case Western Reserve law school

5 of 11 sections researched · 14 sources

Mary DeGenaro

Coverage, by section5 of 11 sections researched.Profile: 8 entriesOn the ballot: 0 entriesWhere they stand: Not yet researchedWhat they have said, checked: Not yet researchedRecord in office: 3 entriesMoney: Not yet researchedFinancial interests: Not yet researchedPolling and approval: Not yet researchedElections: 1 entryEndorsements: Not yet researchedSources: 4 entries5 of 11 sections researched · 7 sources
Coverage, by section5 of 11 sections researched.Source: Cracked Buckeye coverage record for Mary DeGenaro, 5 of 11 sections researched · as of 2026-09-25 · Download this chart
The numbers behind this figure, as a table
Coverage, by section
SectionState
profileresearched
ballotresearched
positionsnot researched
claimsnot researched
recordresearched
moneynot researched
interestsnot researched
pollingnot researched
electionsresearched
endorsementsnot researched
sourcesresearched

Melody J. Stewart

Coverage, by section5 of 11 sections researched.Profile: 13 entriesOn the ballot: 0 entriesWhere they stand: Not yet researchedWhat they have said, checked: Not yet researchedRecord in office: 4 entriesMoney: Not yet researchedFinancial interests: Not yet researchedPolling and approval: Not yet researchedElections: 2 entriesEndorsements: Not yet researchedSources: 12 entries5 of 11 sections researched · 14 sources
Coverage, by section5 of 11 sections researched.Source: Cracked Buckeye coverage record for Melody J. Stewart, 5 of 11 sections researched · as of 2026-09-25 · Download this chart
The numbers behind this figure, as a table
Coverage, by section
SectionState
profileresearched
ballotresearched
positionsnot researched
claimsnot researched
recordresearched
moneynot researched
interestsnot researched
pollingnot researched
electionsresearched
endorsementsnot researched
sourcesresearched

The race in pictures

Polls, Justice of the Supreme Court (Full term commencing 1-2-2019), as publishedNo poll of this race is on file yet.None found in the records checked
Polls, Justice of the Supreme Court (Full term commencing 1-2-2019), as publishedNo poll of this race is on file yet.Source: fec.gov · as of 2026-10-31 · Download this chart
The numbers behind this figure, as a table
Polls, Justice of the Supreme Court (Full term commencing 1-2-2019), as published
Status
None found in the records checked
Money, raised, spent and cash on hand, as filedRaised, as filed: DeGenaro not yet researched, Stewart not yet researched.RaisedDeGenaro (R)Mary DeGenaro: raised not yet researchedNot yet researchedStewart (D)Melody J. Stewart: raised not yet researchedNot yet researchedSpentDeGenaro (R)Mary DeGenaro: spent not yet researchedNot yet researchedStewart (D)Melody J. Stewart: spent not yet researchedNot yet researchedCash on handDeGenaro (R)Mary DeGenaro: cash on hand not yet researchedNot yet researchedStewart (D)Melody J. Stewart: cash on hand not yet researchedNot yet researched
Money, raised, spent and cash on hand, as filedRaised, as filed: DeGenaro not yet researched, Stewart not yet researched.Source: FEC filings · as of 2026-10-31 · Download this chart
The numbers behind this figure, as a table
Money, raised, spent and cash on hand, as filed
GroupItemUSDNote
RaisedDeGenaro (R)Not yet researched
RaisedStewart (D)Not yet researched
SpentDeGenaro (R)Not yet researched
SpentStewart (D)Not yet researched
Cash on handDeGenaro (R)Not yet researched
Cash on handStewart (D)Not yet researched

A note on our coverage

Read before the columns: where one candidate has more entries than another, this says which of the two reasons it is.

Sources: Melody J. Stewart has 12 entries and Mary DeGenaro has 4 entries. The difference reflects the length of each public record and the depth of our research; it is not a judgment.

Jump to a candidate

Where they stand

Their own words, by issue, with the date, the venue and the link. A paraphrase is marked as one.

Mary DeGenaro

Not yet researched

Melody J. Stewart

Not yet researched

What they have said, checked

Newest first. Each check is shown in the checker's own rating word, with their name, the date and the link.

Mary DeGenaro

Not yet researched

Melody J. Stewart

Not yet researched

Record in office

Dated actions. Any evaluation of an action is printed with the name of whoever made it and the link.

Record in office, dated entries, both candidates on one axis7 record entries from 2018 to 2024; 7 of them rulings; 4 offices held on the record.20102020DeGenaro (R)Judge, Seventh District Court of Appeals, 2001-02-09 to 2018-01-28Justice of the Supreme Court of Ohio, 2018-01-28 to 2019-01-012018-08-15 (ruling): Wrote the Supreme Court of Ohio's majority opinion in State v. Carnes, 2018-Ohio-3256, which held that using juvenile adjudications as a bas2018-11-06 (ruling): Wrote the Supreme Court of Ohio's majority opinion in Daher v. Cuyahoga Community College Dist., 2018-Ohio-4462, which held that a trial jud2018-12-13 (ruling): Joined the majority in Blackstone v. Moore, 2018-Ohio-4959, and wrote a separate concurring opinion cautioning that the holding should not bStewart (D)Judge, Eighth District Court of Appeals, 2006 to 2019-01Justice of the Supreme Court of Ohio, 2019-01-02 to 2025-01-012020-11-05 (ruling): Wrote the Supreme Court of Ohio's majority opinion in State ex rel. Cable News Network, Inc. v. Bellbrook-Sugarcreek Local Schools, 2020-Ohi2022-01-12 (ruling): Wrote the Supreme Court of Ohio's majority opinion in League of Women Voters of Ohio v. Ohio Redistricting Commission, 2022-Ohio-65, which h2022-10-12 (ruling): Wrote the Supreme Court of Ohio's majority opinion in Cruz v. English Nanny & Governess School, 2022-Ohio-3586, which held that parties awar2024-08-06 (ruling): Wrote the Supreme Court of Ohio's majority opinion in Harmon v. Cincinnati, 2024-Ohio-2889, which held that two city employees placed on pan
Record in office, dated entries, both candidates on one axis7 record entries from 2018 to 2024; 7 of them rulings; 4 offices held on the record.Source: Cracked Buckeye person record for DeGenaro (R) and Stewart (D), 7 dated entries · as of 2024-08-06 · Download this chart
The numbers behind this figure, as a table
Record in office, dated entries, both candidates on one axis
PersonDateKindEntry
DeGenaro (R)2001-02-09officeJudge, Seventh District Court of Appeals
DeGenaro (R)2018-01-28officeJustice of the Supreme Court of Ohio
DeGenaro (R)2018-08-15ruling2018-08-15 (ruling): Wrote the Supreme Court of Ohio's majority opinion in State v. Carnes, 2018-Ohio-3256, which held that using juvenile adjudications as a bas
DeGenaro (R)2018-11-06ruling2018-11-06 (ruling): Wrote the Supreme Court of Ohio's majority opinion in Daher v. Cuyahoga Community College Dist., 2018-Ohio-4462, which held that a trial jud
DeGenaro (R)2018-12-13ruling2018-12-13 (ruling): Joined the majority in Blackstone v. Moore, 2018-Ohio-4959, and wrote a separate concurring opinion cautioning that the holding should not b
Stewart (D)2006officeJudge, Eighth District Court of Appeals
Stewart (D)2019-01-02officeJustice of the Supreme Court of Ohio
Stewart (D)2020-11-05ruling2020-11-05 (ruling): Wrote the Supreme Court of Ohio's majority opinion in State ex rel. Cable News Network, Inc. v. Bellbrook-Sugarcreek Local Schools, 2020-Ohi
Stewart (D)2022-01-12ruling2022-01-12 (ruling): Wrote the Supreme Court of Ohio's majority opinion in League of Women Voters of Ohio v. Ohio Redistricting Commission, 2022-Ohio-65, which h
Stewart (D)2022-10-12ruling2022-10-12 (ruling): Wrote the Supreme Court of Ohio's majority opinion in Cruz v. English Nanny & Governess School, 2022-Ohio-3586, which held that parties awar
Stewart (D)2024-08-06ruling2024-08-06 (ruling): Wrote the Supreme Court of Ohio's majority opinion in Harmon v. Cincinnati, 2024-Ohio-2889, which held that two city employees placed on pan

Mary DeGenaro

  1. December 13, 2018 · ruling

    Joined the majority in Blackstone v. Moore, 2018-Ohio-4959, and wrote a separate concurring opinion cautioning that the holding should not be read to extend the general Marketable Title Act to mineral interests governed by the Dormant Mineral Act.

    Source: Specific References in Deed Sufficient to Preserve Oil and Gas Rights

  2. November 6, 2018 · ruling

    Wrote the Supreme Court of Ohio's majority opinion in Daher v. Cuyahoga Community College Dist., 2018-Ohio-4462, which held that a trial judge's in camera inspection of sealed grand jury materials is not a final, appealable order.

    Source: Trial Judge's Inspection of Secret Grand Jury Proceedings Cannot Be Immediately Appealed

  3. August 15, 2018 · ruling

    Wrote the Supreme Court of Ohio's majority opinion in State v. Carnes, 2018-Ohio-3256, which held that using juvenile adjudications as a basis for barring adult firearm possession under R.C. 2923.13 does not violate due process.

    Source: Juvenile Offenses Can Be Used to Convict Adult of Illegal Firearm Possession

Melody J. Stewart

  1. August 6, 2024 · ruling

    Wrote the Supreme Court of Ohio's majority opinion in Harmon v. Cincinnati, 2024-Ohio-2889, which held that two city employees placed on pandemic emergency leave could appeal the Cincinnati Civil Service Commission's decision to the common pleas court, and affirmed the First District.

    Sources: Harmon v. Cincinnati, 2024-Ohio-2889 · Cincinnati Workers Entitled to Hearing on City’s Decision to Place Them on Leave During Pandemic · Opinions by Justice Melody J. Stewart

  2. October 12, 2022 · ruling

    Wrote the Supreme Court of Ohio's majority opinion in Cruz v. English Nanny & Governess School, 2022-Ohio-3586, which held that parties awarded attorney fees with a punitive-damages award may also recover the fees they incur defending that judgment on appeal.

    Sources: Cruz v. English Nanny & Governess School, 2022-Ohio-3586 · To Collect Punitive Damages Award, Attorneys Can Charge Opponent for Cost of Appeals · Opinions by Justice Melody J. Stewart

  3. January 12, 2022 · ruling

    Wrote the Supreme Court of Ohio's majority opinion in League of Women Voters of Ohio v. Ohio Redistricting Commission, 2022-Ohio-65, which held the commission's September 2021 General Assembly district plan invalid under Article XI, Sections 6(A) and 6(B), and ordered a new plan within ten days.

    Sources: League of Women Voters of Ohio v. Ohio Redistricting Comm., 2022-Ohio-65 · Opinions by Justice Melody J. Stewart

  4. November 5, 2020 · ruling

    Wrote the Supreme Court of Ohio's majority opinion in State ex rel. Cable News Network, Inc. v. Bellbrook-Sugarcreek Local Schools, 2020-Ohio-5149, which held that the Ohio Student Privacy Act bars release of a deceased adult former student's school records without that student's written consent.

    Sources: State ex rel. Cable News Network, Inc. v. Bellbrook-Sugarcreek Local Schools, 2020-Ohio-5149 · School Not Required to Release Records of Deceased Dayton Shooter · Opinions by Justice Melody J. Stewart

Money

Totals and donors exactly as filed with the FEC or the Ohio Secretary of State, each figure with its filing link.

Itemized contributions from inside Ohio, share of all itemizedNo filing in this race breaks itemized contributions down by state.None found in the records checked
Itemized contributions from inside Ohio, share of all itemizedNo filing in this race breaks itemized contributions down by state.Source: fec.gov · as of 2026-10-31 · Download this chart
The numbers behind this figure, as a table
Itemized contributions from inside Ohio, share of all itemized
Status
None found in the records checked

Mary DeGenaro

Where the money went, as filedNo campaign finance filing is on file for Mary DeGenaro in this race yet.None found in the records checked
Where the money went, as filedNo campaign finance filing is on file for Mary DeGenaro in this race yet.Source: fec.gov · as of 2026-10-31 · Download this chart
The numbers behind this figure, as a table
Where the money went, as filed
Status
None found in the records checked

Totals as filed

Not yet researched

Top donors, as filed

Not yet researched

Outside spending

Not yet researched

In-state share

Not yet researched

Melody J. Stewart

Where the money went, as filedNo campaign finance filing is on file for Melody J. Stewart in this race yet.None found in the records checked
Where the money went, as filedNo campaign finance filing is on file for Melody J. Stewart in this race yet.Source: fec.gov · as of 2026-10-31 · Download this chart
The numbers behind this figure, as a table
Where the money went, as filed
Status
None found in the records checked

Totals as filed

Not yet researched

Top donors, as filed

Not yet researched

Outside spending

Not yet researched

In-state share

Not yet researched

The result

Past election results, share of the vote1 prior race on file across 2 candidates; none on file for DeGenaro.DeGenaroMary DeGenaro: no prior race on fileno prior race on fileStewart2024 Supreme CourtMelody J. Stewart, Justice of the Supreme Court (Full term commencing 1-2-2025): lost, 44.9%44.9%
Past election results, share of the vote1 prior race on file across 2 candidates; none on file for DeGenaro.Source: Ohio Secretary of State, official canvass, 2024 · as of 2024 · Download this chart
The numbers behind this figure, as a table
Past election results, share of the vote
GroupItemPCTNote
DeGenarono prior race on file
Stewart2024 Supreme Court44.9

Melody J. Stewart · certified 2018 · turnout 55.79

CandidateVotesShare
Melody J. Stewart1,853,41852.6%
Mary DeGenaro1,667,25847.4%

Sources: 2018 Ohio elections · 2018 Ohio gubernatorial election

Sources

Data from Wikipedia, CC BY-SA 4.0: 2018 Ohio elections · Ohio Supreme Court elections · 2018 Ohio gubernatorial election · Mary DeGenaro · Melody J. Stewart · 2024 Ohio elections

  1. 2018 Ohio elections · Wikipedia · accessed 2026-09-25
  2. Ohio Supreme Court elections · Wikipedia · accessed 2026-09-25
  3. Judges Donnelly, Stewart Win Seats on Ohio Supreme Court · Court News Ohio (Supreme Court of Ohio) · 2018-11-08 · accessed 2026-09-25
  4. Justice Mary DeGenaro · Supreme Court of Ohio · accessed 2026-09-25
  5. Justice William M. O'Neill · Supreme Court of Ohio · accessed 2026-09-25
  6. 2018 Ohio gubernatorial election · Wikipedia · accessed 2026-09-25
  7. Mary DeGenaro · Wikipedia · accessed 2026-09-24
  8. Specific References in Deed Sufficient to Preserve Oil and Gas Rights · Court News Ohio (Supreme Court of Ohio) · 2018-12-13 · accessed 2026-09-24
  9. Trial Judge's Inspection of Secret Grand Jury Proceedings Cannot Be Immediately Appealed · Court News Ohio (Supreme Court of Ohio) · 2018-11-06 · accessed 2026-09-24
  10. Juvenile Offenses Can Be Used to Convict Adult of Illegal Firearm Possession · Court News Ohio (Supreme Court of Ohio) · 2018-08-15 · accessed 2026-09-24
  11. Melody J. Stewart · Supreme Court of Ohio · accessed 2026-09-24
  12. Melody J. Stewart · Wikipedia · accessed 2026-09-24
  13. Harmon v. Cincinnati, 2024-Ohio-2889 · Supreme Court of Ohio · 2024-08-06 · accessed 2026-09-24
  14. Cincinnati Workers Entitled to Hearing on City’s Decision to Place Them on Leave During Pandemic · Court News Ohio (Supreme Court of Ohio) · 2024-08-06 · accessed 2026-09-24
  15. Opinions by Justice Melody J. Stewart · Supreme Court of Ohio · accessed 2026-09-24
  16. Cruz v. English Nanny & Governess School, 2022-Ohio-3586 · Supreme Court of Ohio · 2022-10-12 · accessed 2026-09-24
  17. To Collect Punitive Damages Award, Attorneys Can Charge Opponent for Cost of Appeals · Court News Ohio (Supreme Court of Ohio) · 2022-10-12 · accessed 2026-09-24
  18. League of Women Voters of Ohio v. Ohio Redistricting Comm., 2022-Ohio-65 · Supreme Court of Ohio · 2022-01-12 · accessed 2026-09-24
  19. State ex rel. Cable News Network, Inc. v. Bellbrook-Sugarcreek Local Schools, 2020-Ohio-5149 · Supreme Court of Ohio · 2020-11-05 · accessed 2026-09-24
  20. School Not Required to Release Records of Deceased Dayton Shooter · Court News Ohio (Supreme Court of Ohio) · 2020-11-05 · accessed 2026-09-24
  21. 2024 Ohio elections · Wikipedia · accessed 2026-09-24
  22. 2024 General Election Candidates · Franklin County Board of Elections · accessed 2026-09-24

Quick answers

When was the 2018 Justice of the Supreme Court (Full term commencing 1-2-2019) election in Ohio?

The election for Justice of the Supreme Court (Full term commencing 1-2-2019) was held on November 6, 2018.

Who ran for Justice of the Supreme Court (Full term commencing 1-2-2019) in 2018?

On the ballot for Justice of the Supreme Court (Full term commencing 1-2-2019), in surname order: Mary DeGenaro (Republican), Melody J. Stewart (Democratic).

Who won the 2018 Justice of the Supreme Court (Full term commencing 1-2-2019) election?

Melody J. Stewart won the election for Justice of the Supreme Court (Full term commencing 1-2-2019). Results as certified: Mary DeGenaro 47.4%, Melody J. Stewart 52.6%.

Cite and data

Cite this page as:

Cracked Buckeye, "Justice of the Supreme Court (Full term commencing 1-2-2019), 2018", https://crackedbuckeye.com/election/2018/supreme-court-jan-2-2019/, built 2026-10-31, accessed [date].

How to cite · Report a correction · Built 2026-10-31