Our reporting · electric bills

Why the AEP bill in Columbus went up

A typical AEP Ohio bill in Columbus was $96.13 in September 2020 and $168.95 in September 2026. AEP's own rate sheets show what drove it: energy prices in 2022-23, then a capacity charge that climbed from a 2024 low of $2.40 to $19.94 a month.

Published 2026-11-10 · Correct this page · hello@crackedbuckeye.com

In September 2020, a typical AEP Ohio home in Columbus paid $96.13 for a month of electricity. In September 2026, the same home paid $168.95. That is $72.82 more, up 76%.

The "typical home" is the one the Public Utilities Commission of Ohio (PUCO) prices every month: 750 kilowatt-hours, on AEP's standard service, including the state's kilowatt-hour tax. The newest month, October 2026, is $162.82; October to October, the rise since 2020 is 64%. The bill has been this high before: it was $169.26 in April and May 2024, then fell when energy prices dropped that June.

The September bill, 2015 to 2026

Flat for six years, then two big steps up.

2015$103.45
2016$100.97
2017$95.48
2018$97.47
2019$91.04
2020$96.13
2021$103.15
2022$120.24
2023$154.59
2024$142.07
2025$155.83
2026$168.95
The numbers
SeptemberBill
2015$103.45
2016$100.97
2017$95.48
2018$97.47
2019$91.04
2020$96.13
2021$103.15
2022$120.24
2023$154.59
2024$142.07
2025$155.83
2026$168.95

Source: PUCO Ohio Utility Rate Survey, Columbus, Ohio Power (Columbus Southern Power rate zone), schedule RS.

Two waves

2022 and 2023: the price of energy. AEP buys the power for its standard-service customers at auction, and those prices jumped. AEP's energy charge alone rose $34.11 a month in June 2023, from $45.31 to $79.42 for the same 750 kWh.

Since the summer of 2024: one charge most people have never heard of. Between July 2024 and July 2026 the bill rose $27.33, from $141.10 to $168.43. AEP's own rate sheets split every line of it. The Generation Capacity Rider went from $2.40 a month to $19.94. That is $17.54, nearly two-thirds of the rise. A true-up rider for AEP's power auctions added $3.33, the energy charge $3.65 and distribution $3.11, and transmission fell 30 cents.

$2.40 was the capacity charge's low point. In January 2022, when AEP's rate sheets in our set begin, it was $12.88. Over that whole stretch, January 2022 to July 2026, the bill rose $64.45: energy $32.76, distribution $11.36, transmission $10.62, capacity $7.06 and the true-up rider and smaller charges the rest.

What a 750 kWh bill paid for, July 2024 and July 2026

The orange slice is the capacity charge, from its 2024 low of $2.40 to $19.94.

Capacity chargeRest of generationTransmissionDistribution
July 2024
$141.10
July 2026
$168.43
The numbers
Billing monthCapacity chargeRest of generationTransmissionDistributionPUCO bill
July 2024$2.40$55.34$32.88$50.48$141.10
July 2026$19.94$62.33$32.58$53.59$168.43

The parts add to the PUCO bill to within a cent of rounding.

Source: AEP Ohio billing-analysis workbooks for the Columbus Southern rate zone, July 2024 and July 2026.

What the capacity charge is

PJM runs the power grid for Ohio, 12 other states and Washington, D.C. Every year it holds an auction to pay power plants to stand ready for the hottest days. The more demand PJM expects, the more standby power it buys, and the higher the price. Everyone on the grid pays that price, data centers included. AEP passes it straight through to customers, inside the line on the bill called generation.

PJM's capacity price, dollars per megawatt per day

The price fell for three years, then rose more than nine times over in one auction.

2021/22$140.00
2022/23$50.00
2023/24$34.13
2024/25$28.92
2025/26$269.92
2026/27$329.17

Source: PJM Base Residual Auction results, RTO clearing price by delivery year (June to May).

How much of it is data centers?

PJM's independent market monitor re-ran the last four auctions with data-center demand taken out of the forecasts they used. Its answer: data-center demand accounts for $29.4 billion, or 46.2%, of all the capacity charges those auctions set, across the whole 13-state grid. Two of those four auctions set the prices on bills now; the other two take effect in 2027 and 2028. The monitor says prices would have risen without data centers, but less. We found no published figure for Ohio alone.

Ohio's regulators did act on part of this. Since July 2025, new data centers on AEP's system must pay for at least 85 percent of the power they reserve, for up to 12 years. That rule covers what AEP builds for them. It does not cover the capacity price, which every customer pays.

The records

  1. PUCO, Ohio Utility Rate Survey, September 2020 (Columbus: $96.13): PUCO survey PDF
  2. PUCO, Utility Rate Survey dashboard, every month and city since 2015 (download as CSV): PUCO dashboard
  3. AEP Ohio billing analysis, July 2024 (capacity rider 0.32 cents per kWh): archived workbook
  4. AEP Ohio billing analysis, July 2026 (capacity rider 2.659 cents per kWh): archived workbook. AEP removes old workbooks from its own site when rates change.
  5. PJM capacity auction results: PJM Capacity Market (RPM)
  6. Monitoring Analytics, PJM's independent market monitor, report to the Members Committee, July 28, 2026, slide 4: market monitor PDF
  7. PUCO data-center tariff order, case 24-508-EL-ATA, July 9, 2025.

Corrected November 10, 2026. The first version said the bill was before tax; it includes the state's kilowatt-hour tax. We also added that the capacity charge was $12.88 in January 2022 before falling to its 2024 low, the October-to-October rise, the bill's spring 2024 peak, the auction true-up rider, and the earlier years of PJM's price.

More findings

Cite

Cite this page as:

Cracked Buckeye, "Why the AEP bill in Columbus went up", https://crackedbuckeye.com/findings/aep-columbus-bill-2020-2026/, built 2026-11-14, accessed [date].

How to cite · Report a correction · Built 2026-11-14