How does Ohio compare? Pay, pensions, power shutoffs and stadiums
Ohio makes its own rules on the lowest wage, public workers' unions and pensions, shutting off power for unpaid bills, and paying for stadiums. Here is how each one works, and where Ohio stands among the other states.
What is an hour of work worth in Ohio?
Ohio sets its own lowest wage. It is written into the state constitution, and it goes up every 1 January by as much as prices went up. The federal minimum, the floor for every state, has been stuck at $7.25 since July 2009.
Each September the state checks how much prices rose over the past year (the federal CPI-W price index). On 1 January the wage rises by the same share, rounded to the nearest 5 cents.
What it meansBecause Ohio's wage climbs with prices, it has pulled well ahead of Pennsylvania, Indiana and Kentucky, which still use $7.25. But Ohio is still in the middle of the country: 26 states and Washington, D.C. set a higher wage, led by D.C. at $18.40. Next door, Michigan pays $13.73.
How many Ohio workers are in a union? And what happened when lawmakers tried to limit them?
In 1983, about 1 in 4 Ohio workers belonged to a union (25.1%). By 2025 it was about 1 in 9 (11.7%, or about 606,000 people), a little above the country as a whole.
Almost all of the drop came in private businesses: from 22.5% of their workers in 1983 to 7.2% in 2025. Among government workers, such as teachers, police and firefighters, 40.9% belonged to a union in 2025, about as many as in 1983 (39.3%).
Senate Bill 5: the law voters threw out
In 2011 Ohio lawmakers passed Senate Bill 5. It would have banned strikes by government workers, narrowed what their unions could bargain over, made them pay at least 15% of their health insurance, and replaced automatic pay steps with pay tied to performance.
- 1Lawmakers pass the law in 2011.
- 2Opponents file a petition for a statewide vote on it, called a referendum, so the law cannot take effect until voters decide. On the ballot it was Issue 2.
- 3Voters decide, 8 November 2011. Watch the counties fill in, west to east.
The strongest votes against the law came in Athens (81%), Scioto (76%), Vinton (76%).
Big strikes have become rare. The U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics lists 46 strikes and lockouts of 1,000 workers or more since 1993 that reached Ohio; 37 of them began before 2010. The biggest began in March 1996, when about 3,000 workers struck two General Motors brake plants in Dayton. Within 17 days GM plants across North America had shut down for want of brakes; the Bureau counts 136,000 U.S. workers involved.
What it meansUnions shrank in Ohio's private businesses but held steady among government workers. When lawmakers tried to limit those government unions, voters in all but 5 counties said no, by about 3 votes to 2.
Will the money be there for retired teachers, police and other public workers?
Every payday, a public worker and the employer both put money into a big pension fund. The fund invests it so it grows. Retirees get a check every month for life. The big question: has the fund saved enough for everything it has promised?
- 12001: the teachers' fund had 91% of what it owed.
- 22009: after the 2008 stock market crash, 60%.
- 32012: the low point, 56.0%. Lawmakers passed five laws that year, one for each fund.
- 42025: back to 80.9%, after those laws and years of market gains.
The 2012 laws asked more of workers and retirees. Teachers now pay 14% of every paycheck into the fund, up from 10%. Many workers must wait longer before they can retire with a full pension. And yearly raises for retirees got smaller: the teachers' fund gave none from July 2017 until a one-time 3% raise in July 2022. Since then it has given small one-time raises (1% in 2023, 1.5% in 2025) to people who retired before set dates.
Ohio's five funds in 2025
The water shows the share of promised pensions each fund has saved (its latest yearly report to the Ohio Retirement Study Council). The dashed line at the top is 100%.
Police and fire is the weakest, at 66.4%. At its current pace it would take 30.9 years to pay off what it owes, just past the 30-year limit in Ohio law; a fund past the limit must send lawmakers a plan to get back under it. And fewer workers are paying in for each retiree: in 2001 the biggest fund, for public workers (OPERS), had about 3 working members for every retiree. In 2025 it had about 1.4 (the two years come from different reports).
The plans in the national Public Plans Data survey, each state's added together (dollars saved over dollars promised). Ohio's are the public workers', teachers', school staff, and police and fire funds, plus Cincinnati's city fund. The middle state saved 77%.
What it meansOhio's public pensions are in the better half of the country: in 2024 their big plans together had saved 81% of what they promise, 20th of 51 (the 50 states and D.C.). That came after a hard fix in 2012 that made workers and retirees cover much of the gap. Police and fire is still the fund to watch.
How often does Ohio cut off people's power for unpaid bills?
When a bill goes unpaid, the power company sends a warning, and then it can switch the power off. In 2024 Ohio's six big electric companies reported 287,029 shutoffs of homes, out of about 4.1 million home accounts.
Some homes are cut off more than once in a year, so these are shutoffs, not separate homes.
Where it happens most
AEP Ohio alone made 60% of the shutoffs these six companies reported in 2024 (172,573). In 2020, when shutoffs nearly stopped from April to August as the pandemic began, the rate fell to 35 per 1,000, from 76 the year before.
Only states whose utilities report enough data are counted (23 of them), and states count shutoffs in different ways, so small gaps between states mean little.
Help with the bill
- 1PIPP Plus. A household earning up to 175% of the poverty line (the limit in 2024) pays a set share of its monthly income instead of the full bill: 5% for its electric and/or gas service, or 10% if the home uses only electric. Each full payment on time takes 1/24 off the old debt.
- 2HEAP. A once-a-year payment toward heating. In the 2023 federal year Ohio helped 265,455 households with heating, crisis or cooling aid, about 20% of the 1,297,469 households poor enough to qualify. That share ranks 26th of 50 states; Michigan (90%) reached the most. Ohio's average heating payment was $394.
What it meansOhio shuts off power for unpaid bills more often than most states: it is among the five highest of the 23 states we could compare, at about 1.8 times the middle state's rate. Pennsylvania and Indiana are close to Ohio. Inside Ohio, most of the shutoffs come from one company's area: AEP Ohio's.
Who paid for Ohio's big-league stadiums?
In the deals we could document, taxes paid a big share of the cost of Ohio's big-league stadiums. The usual way it works: voters approve a tax, the county borrows a big sum all at once by selling bonds, the stadium gets built, and then the tax pays the loan back for decades.
Loan payments are principal and interest on the bonds for both stadiums, from the county's 2017 audit.
A half-cent sales tax, since 1996
Hamilton County voters added half a cent to the sales tax in March 1996 to build two stadiums. At the end of 2017 the county still owed $411.9 million on the stadium bonds. Under their lease the Reds have paid $1 a year in rent since 2012. The Bengals' base rent was $500,000 a year through 2018.
Taxes on alcohol and cigarettes, since 1990
Cuyahoga County's "sin taxes" helped pay for the ballpark and arena, a $425 million project by 1999. The city of Cleveland spent about $289 million on the Browns' stadium, which opened in 1999, mostly borrowed, with money from the team's owner and state grants; the team's rent was $250,000 a year in 2002. Voters extended the sin tax in 2014 for 20 more years. In 2017 the county borrowed $141 million to renovate the arena, with the Cavaliers' rent covering half.
Casino taxes
In 2012 a public authority bought Nationwide Arena for $42.5 million, borrowed from Nationwide ($32.5 million) and the state ($10 million). The city's and county's casino tax money runs the arena first, and what is left pays the loans. In 2014 it fell short, so the state put off its interest until 2021 (separately, it cut $500,000 from its loan for meeting job targets). The Blue Jackets agreed to keep playing there until September 2039.
Money people forgot
The 2025 state budget set aside $600 million for a big stadium project in Brook Park, the Browns' planned new home, paid from unclaimed money the state holds for people, such as forgotten bank accounts. The state may pay up to a quarter of the building cost (land not counted) and the team must pay at least half, so the full grant means a stadium costing at least $2.4 billion. A lawsuit over using the unclaimed money led a court to pause the transfers in March 2026, news outlets reported; we have not read the court record.
What it meansIn the deals we could document, taxes that most people pay a little at a time (sales, alcohol and cigarette, casino), or money the state holds for others, paid a big share, and the loans run for decades after opening day. In Cincinnati the county paid $40 million on the stadium loans in 2017, while the Reds paid $1.
We have not yet compared Ohio's stadium deals with other states' deals.
What we could not find yet
- How many Ohio households are on PIPP Plus, and how much they owe, utility by utility.
- Water shutoffs in Ohio's big cities. No city publishes a count we could use.
- The vote counts for the 1996 Hamilton County stadium tax and the Cuyahoga County sin-tax votes, and the full cost of the Browns' Brook Park stadium.
- Each pension fund's own yearly reports for 2001 to 2020 (we used the national Public Plans Data, which is built from them).
Know something we got wrong, or have a document we missed? Tell us, and we will fix it in the open.